My gaze widened to notice the rest of her family, and my brain delayed the order.
When I looked back at her, she’d stopped talking and the happy expression on her face was frozen. She looked a lot like she had when she’d come into Biff’s.
“What are you doing here?” she asked in a strained voice. Her panic-filled eyes were glued to me.
It wasn’t the reaction I’d expected. Maybe she didn’t like surprises.
“I wanted to see you. This your family?”
The woman seated beside Kayla, obviously her mother, gasped and stared at me like I had emerged from a smoke-filled tunnel at the start of the Super Bowl. “Are you Jason?” She looked excited. “Kayla’s told us . . . well, not a whole lot about you. Grab a chair! Join us.”
Had she just called me Jason?
It was noisy. I must not have heard her right. I glanced around and located an empty chair at a nearby table. The couple there just stared at me when I asked if I could borrow it. I pulled it up to the end of the booth and sat. “Sorry. I drove down to surprise Kayla.”
The guy closest to me, who had to be her brother Cooper, had a shit-eating grin. “She looks surprised, for sure.”
Kayla’s dad was exactly how I expected. He gave off the same vibe my coaches did. Friendly, but evaluating. Twenty bucks said he still reached for a nonexistent whistle hanging around his neck when he saw an OSU play falling apart. His gaze drilled down into me, making me feel like I’d shown up five minutes late to his practice.
“I’m sorry, you drove down?” he asked. “You don’t go here?”
He didn’t know that? I glanced at Kayla, who stared at the tabletop. What the hell was going on? “No.” I cleared my throat, trying to get her attention. She wouldn’t even look at me. “I go to Michigan.”
“—State,” she said abruptly, her focus darting nervously from one parent to the other. “He goes to Michigan State.”
What the fuck? I probably should have expected it, but my jaw nearly hit the table. “You haven’t told them?”
“You go to MSU?” Kayla’s mother straightened sharply, and she turned to her daughter. “Is that why you didn’t tell us about him? It’s not that big of a deal.” Although her tight voice said otherwise. Her attention returned to me, and she looked way less excited now. “Jason, I’m Stephanie, Kayla’s mom.”
So, I hadn’t misheard her. What was I supposed to do? Correct her? Announce to Kayla’s family that she hadn’t even told them my actual name? I went on autopilot, and my tone was flat. “Nice to meet you.”
“Hey, man. I’m Cooper.” The kid held his hand out, and when I took it in a handshake, he used it to pull himself closer to me. His voice went low. “Someone’s going to recognize you. Someone besides me.”
Cooper flashed an easy smile. He wasn’t surprised. At least her brother knew, so that was . . . something? I glanced around, and my heartbeat quickened. Oh shit. Was that Vaughn, Ohio State’s head coach, in the corner? And the entire coaching staff? When Kayla told me about her family tradition, I knew the bar might be hostile, but I hadn’t realized I’d be walking into a lion’s den.
“You catch any of the game?” her dad asked, bringing my attention back to her family. “Kayla said you like football.”
Oh, did she? Once again, she was staring at the table. Irritation dug at me, burrowing deeper with each second she refused to look my direction. “Yeah,” I ground out. “I play, but I had practice earlier.”
There were flat screens all around this sports bar, and the highlights from the Michigan State game were running on the Big Ten Network. I watched skepticism grow on her father’s face as he watched the Spartans score a touchdown at home. “Who do you play for?”
I’d wanted to make a good first impression with her folks, but that had gone out the window as soon as I sat down. And she still wouldn’t fucking look at me. “Why didn’t you tell them, Kayla?” I demanded, filling my voice with sarcasm. “Is it because I’m so awesome, you were afraid they wouldn’t think I’m real?”
A guy was trying to get down the aisle and tripped over the back of my chair, interrupting us. I glared up at him.
“Whoops, sorry, bud—” He stared at me hard, searching the database of his brain. “Do I know you?”
Cooper chose that moment to stand. “Hey, you know where the bathroom is? Is it that way?” He gestured to the back of the restaurant, trying to drag the guy away.
“Haven’t you been coming here since birth?” The guy fired back, not taking his gaze off me. Shit. The lightbulb went on in the man’s head, and his face dropped with surprise. He turned to Kayla’s dad in visible disbelief. “Bob, you realize who this is? What’s he doing here? And at your table?”