I come up and kiss her mouth quickly. “Can’t come up with a word for it, eh? I’m going to assume that’s a good sign you’re not anti-anal.”
“I didn’t think I’d like you messing around there but I think it’s safe to say I’m not anti-anal.”
“Good. Because I really want to fuck your ass. Do you have any lube?”
“I’ve never slept with any man but you, so what do you think?”
“I think I like hearing you say that. And I think it’s a good thing you just came so much it’s dripping down your crack.”
I grasp my cock and rub the tip through her cum. “Don’t worry, Ash baby. I’m going to make this so fucking good for you.”
Her brow wrinkles. “You don’t want me doggie-style?”
“Not this time but I will when I can use my arm again. I’ll want to dig my fingers into that juicy ass so I can pound it good.”
I kiss the top of her knee. “Ready?”
“If you are.” Her words aren’t incredibly convincing but I’m going to show her how good this can be for both of us.
“I won’t do anything without telling you first.” This is different from fucking. I can’t just jump in and start pounding away or she’ll never let me near it a second time. And I already know I’m going to very much want to fuck this tight hole again.
“Just breathe and relax, baby. I’m only positioning. Not going in yet.”
She takes a deep breath and exhales slowly. “OK. I’m relaxing it.”
I push and retreat as I simultaneously tell her what I’m doing. “I’m rocking with shorter strokes. It’ll go in easier like that. How’s it feel?”
“Burns a little when you push in but I’m OK.”
She’s going to be so much better than OK after I’m inside her. “Tell me if anything hurts.”
She nods and then gasps when I push beyond the tight ring inside her. “You’re in?”
“I’m in. Still doing all right?”
“I’m good. Much better now.”
I push her legs back and move a little faster, although it doesn’t come close to matching the way I pound into her pussy. “Your ass is mine now. No other man will ever be inside it like this.”
“Only yours.”
She rocks her hips in counteraction with mine. “I think you like my cock in your ass.”
“Maybe a little.”
I push her legs apart and rub her clit. “I want you to come with me. I want to feel you clamp down on my dick and milk it for every drop of cum it has.”
She reaches over her head and fists the comforter. “Omigod. It’s already starting. And it feels like it’s coming from somewhere so deep.”
“It’s a different kind of orgasm, Ash. Deeper.” Her pussy quivers and her body grips my cock tightly, causing the onset of my own orgasm. “Fuck, Ash. Fuck, you’re squeezing me so tight.” I hiss when I thrust the last time.
I pull out and collapse on the bed beside Ashlyn. “I was the only one who’d ever had your pussy. Now, I’m the only one who’s ever had your ass. They’re both mine and no other man will ever have them. Say it.”
“I belong to you. My pussy is yours. My ass is yours.” She laces her fingers through mine. “And my heart is yours. Forever.”