I zoom for it and swing it open. Alex looks a little startled. “Whoa, that was quick.”
“I was already up, Josie just got here,” I explain as I escort him in.
“You guys want anything? Coffee? Tea?” I offer.
They both shake their heads. “Can we sit?” Alex asks.
I nod, and Josie and I settle on the couch while Alex sits in the chair to the side so he can face us more easily. “I want to apologize for ruining last night,” he says, and I open my mouth to say something, but he stops me, “Hang on, just…let me say this, okay?”
Another nod, and he goes on. “I acted like a jackass. You guys were vulnerable with me, and honest, and in return, I acted like a bratty child and stormed out in a huff. And I’m sorry. I took everything the wrong way, and rather than let you guys explain, I ran away. And that doesn’t work in any relationship, especially one like this. Communication is the most important thing to making this work, and I…I really, really want this to work, because I know it’s fucking nuts to feel like this, but I think I’m falling in love with you both.”
A smile spreads across my face, and I can see that happy tears are trickling down Josie’s cheeks. “Apparently we’re just as crazy as you are, Alex, because we both feel the same way,” I say, “I love you, and I love Josie, even though that scares the hell out of me.”
Josie nods in agreement, but she’s a little too choked up to speak.
“So, I have a proposal,” Alex says.
We both eye him with interest. “Let’s rewind the clock back to last night and try this again,” he suggests, with a smirk that sends a rush of blood straight to my groin.
I grin. “I think I could be amenable to that. Josie? What do you think?”
“I can do that.”
So just like last night, the three of us scramble down the hall like horny teenagers, clothes coming off the whole way. But this time, instead of burying my face between Josie’s thighs, I turn to Alex. “I think it’s your turn to take a taste.”
“Don’t mind if I do,” he says, pushing her down in the middle of the bed and shoving her thighs apart.
She seems to like being manhandled a little, and god, it’s fucking hot to watch. He hoists her legs over his shoulders and dives in, his tongue attacking her pussy and making her squirm helplessly beneath him.
I take the time to go for the condoms and lube. The sight of his ass in the air while he’s bent over eating her out is more than a little enticing, and I pour a little lube into my hand to tease him with my fingers and start warming him up.
Even though this was supposed to be a re-do of last night, I don’t think any of us are going to forget what we did, so it seems only fair to switch things around for our second time.
And I’ve been itching to bury my dick in that sweet ass of his ever since I first laid eyes on it.
He brings her to a screaming climax, and when he straightens, the sight of his face smeared with her juices nearly makes me fucking blow my load right there.
I kiss him, licking his lips clean of her arousal, and he shoves his tongue in my mouth so I can fully taste her, taste them.
I can’t take the waiting anymore. I thrust a condom into his hand. “Your turn to be in the middle,” I direct him, and he nods.
He rolls on the latex, then kneels between our paramour’s thighs and plunges into her dripping snatch. Her nails dig into his back and she screams his name. But he stills, waiting for me.
So I’m quick to pour more lube and work first one, then another, then a third finger into his ass, teasing and stretching the tight hole until it’s slick and ready for me. I slick my cock with an extra helping of lube, then position the head at his entrance. “Ready?”
He nods, and slowly, I push my cock into his ass. He lets out a little hiss at first, then relaxes, and when I sink all the way in, he lets out a groan.
I start to move, and his groans get louder. And with every thrust, I push him into Josie, so her moans join the chorus until their sounds of pleasure form an exquisite harmony.
I’ve had plenty of sex in my life, but cheesy as it sounds, being with Josie and Alex feels like making love for the first time. And maybe it is. Maybe that’s why this relationship feels so different, because finally the right pieces have come together to create something real.
I’m so worked up, it doesn’t take too long before I’m on the brink, but I keep pushing through until both of them are breathing raggedly and I can tell they’re as close as I am.
I try my best to time it right, to get them both off at once and explode right along with them, but Josie’s hair trigger goes off a little early, and her orgasm seemed to set off Alex’s.
I’m just seconds behind, though, and it doesn’t matter. We’re all just a happy tangle of sated, sweaty, lovesick bliss, and this moment is perfect exactly the way it is.