*******
Lying in bed that evening, after they’d thoroughly and slowly loved Keeley, Nate had time to reflect on what went down with her father. Looking down at her sleeping between him and Ty, Nate felt an innate sense of relief that they came home early. He kept obsessing over the fact that had they not, she would probably be dead. Having to shoot someone was never easy, but killing them always had his heart, mind, and conscience waging war on him. His heart knew he loved Keeley, his head knew he had to protect her at all costs. But his conscience knew he’d killed another human being, and it was eating away at his soul. It was not something he could just brush off. Nate knew it would take time to heal from, so he just hoped she could forgive him for his part in her father’s death. The thought of losing her left him feeling panicky and overwhelmed. He needed her in their lives; she was as essential to them as breathing. There was nothing they wouldn’t do for her. Killing her father wasn’t an easy thing to do, but he knew it was either her father or Keeley.
The following morning Nate slipped out of bed. Shaking Ty awake he whispered, “We need to talk”, before heading to the shower, knowing Ty would follow suit by getting up quietly and showering in another washroom.
Ten minutes later, Nate was in the kitchen making coffee when Ty strolled in. Not wanting to put it off he said, “I want to marry her. I want to ask her tonight.”
Looking towards Ty, he had a huge smile on his face. Relief surged through Nate, knowing they were on the same page where Keeley was concerned. “Good, I’ll call the dads and see if they still have Nonna’s engagement ring stored for us.” As Nate called their parents, Ty started making bacon and scrambled eggs, knowing she wouldn’t sleep too long once they left the bed.
After a solid fifteen minutes of listening to their mother squealing about the fact that they were asking Keeley to marry them, Nate was finally able to get off the phone. As he was hanging up, she walked into the kitchen scowling and said, “You left me.” Grabbing a coffee mug to fill for her, Nate handed it to her, getting a quick kiss in before she could complain much more. “Sorry Butterfly, we just didn’t want to wake you up.” He smiled at her. “Mom and the dads will be by early this afternoon though.” Seeing her face light up over that made him happy. Happy that she loved his parents, and happy his parents loved her enough to treat her like a second daughter.
As soon as Ty placed her food in front of her, she dug in saying, “I’m so hungry I could eat for two!”, before diving back in, making him and Ty look at each other. Knowing they were thinking the same thing—Could she be pregnant? Shaking off the thought, Nate knew it was unlikely but couldn’t help hoping that just maybe she was.
On pins and needles most of the morning, worried about how they were going to propose, Nate went down to the gym to burn off some energy.
After a heavy workout he went upstairs, only to see Ty in the kitchen packing what looked like a picnic. “What’s this?” He asked him.
“Well, I figured we need a plan, right? And Keeley’s not huge on pomp and crowds, so what better way to propose than a candlelight picnic under the stars.” Ty smiled at his brilliant idea.
Clapping him on the back, Nate looked around for their shining star. Not seeing or hearing her anywhere in this house, he looked to Ty with a raised eyebrow. “Oh yes, well mom and the dads got here about twenty minutes ago and the dads have Keeley out back distracted, marveling over that damn dog. I swear, he’s getting all the attention now,” he grumbled. “Mom brought all this in and told me her idea.”
“Ah, so the romance was not your doing then, huh? Did they bring the ring?” Nate asked eager to see it.
Pulling it from his pocket, Ty handed it to Nate saying, “They took it to get cleaned, too. I don’t remember that engraving though. But Mom says it was always there.” Ty said sounding suspicious.
Opening the box, Nate pulled it out and admired the intricate, yet simple design. It was an infinity symbol wrapped around a small blue sapphire. One line had diamonds along it, weaving from one side of the ring and around to the halfway mark, while the other was a smooth white gold that wrapped from one side of the sapphire down and around to where the diamonds ended on the opposite side.
Smiling at how perfect it was, knowing the sapphire was Keeley and the two different weaving lines would represent him and Ty, Showing them all as one love, one life wrapped together, Nate was pleased with it. Noticing the engraving Ty had mentioned, he took a closer look at it; it said 3 lives 1 love. Smiling at it, Nate knew that was from their parents, but it was perfect.
Hearing her and their dads coming, he quickly put it back in the box and shoved it in his pocket. Smiling when she came right to him, giving him a small kiss on the lips. “Hi, Nathaniel,” she said sweetly, before moving over to Ty and doing the same.
“Well, we’re gonna head out, you kids have a good evening,” their dad, Andrew, said before waving and grabbing their mom’s hand while she yelled out, “Call me tomorrow, Keeley!”
“Butterfly, come with me, I’ve gotten something for you.” Nate grabbed her hand and led her upstairs, to give her the sexy red dress and matching shoes Bella had given them that day they took her shopping, not so long ago.
*******
Following Nathaniel upstairs, Keeley wondered at their odd behavior today. They kept giving each other funny looks and they seemed twitchy. Putting it to the back of her mind to ask them about later, she was excited to see what Nathaniel had for her. Stepping into his old room, she followed him to the closet where he pulled out the most beautiful red halter dress she had ever seen. “Oh Nathaniel, it’s beautiful. Thank you,” she effused, taking it from him and holding it to her body, knowing it was going to fit like a glove.
The top would be tight to her skin, from her breasts to her hips, where it would flare out to reach just above her knees. Looking up at Nathaniel, she saw he was smiling and holding a gorgeous pair of red peep-toe pumps that matched. “What’s the occasion?” She asked.
“We just want to have a nice romantic evening, will you wear it?” He asked her with a smug smile on his face, knowing she was in love with the outfit and would wear it for them.
Nodding her head she asked, “When do I need to be ready?”
Looking at his watch he said, “You’ve got two hours.” Kissing her forehead he walked out, leaving
her to scramble to get ready. Thank God, I showered this morning, she thought walking back to their shared room. Knowing immediately that she wouldn’t be able to wear a bra with it, she grabbed the sexiest panties she could find. A pair of white lace boy shorts that she knew hugged her just right to showcase her ass cheeks. They had a cute little black bow on the front that sits just above her pubic line.
Setting her dress and panties on the bed, Keeley went to the bathroom to begin curling her hair in soft spiral curls. Knowing how much Nathaniel and Tyler liked to run their fingers through it, she used very little product. Happy with how it looked, she moved on to makeup. Only using some eye shadow to make her eyes smoky, and a light layer of mascara, she was done.
Looking at the time, she noticed more than an hour had passed. Stripping off her clothes she grabbed her panties, slipping them on and turning to double check in the mirror that they did in fact do wonders for her ass. Smiling, she turned to put the dress on over her head, it glided down her body, stopping when the top hit her hips. Pulling the top of it up, she tied the straps around her neck and adjusted her breasts, so nothing was popping out.
Giving a small tug brought the skirt down to rest where it was meant to. Looking in the mirror, she loved how the top molded to her curves and the bottom was light and flirty, moving with her. Sitting on the settee in the corner, she put on the matching red pumps, very glad that her and the girls did mani/pedis on Friday night, before all the chaos had begun.
Looking herself over she decided to put on a soft pink lipstick, and finding a small barrette with light pink and white flowers, she pulled the hair back behind her ear on the left side. With one last look she was done.
Walking down to the living room, she saw the guys were all ready to go. Nathaniel looked handsome in his navy blue dress pants molded to his thighs, and a white shirt, sleeves rolled to his elbows, and buttoned only half way up. He looked good enough to eat. Looking at Tyler, he was just as delicious. Wearing a pair of white dress pants and a gray button-up shirt, worn similar to Nathaniel, Keeley was ready to strip down right there.