“No, that won’t work,” Sam said resignedly, but firmly. “Let’s trade explanations instead?” She waited for him to agree in advance. Instead he lifted his brows and regarded her in noncommittal silence, so Sam took a major gamble and offered her explanation anyway. She explained why the basket of pears had originally concerned her and she told him exactly how she’d ended up finding and reading his note. When she finished, Sam paused deliberately, in order to lend greater significance to her next comment. “Mr. Valente, do you remember what you wrote in that note?”
He nodded impassively, but the implications of his written words—and what the police would naturally infer from them—registered on him, because his expression became fractionally less guarded and distant than she’d ever seen it.
Sam smiled a little without realizing it. “How did you conclude I’d found the note when I mentioned those two names?”
He hesitated a moment; then he reluctantly answered her. “I specifically wrote those names on my note because they were the only names Leigh knew me by in the old days. Now ask yourself a question,” he instructed shortly. “Do you think I would have needed to further identify myself on my own letterhead if she already knew who Michael Valente was?”
Sam shook her head. “No,” she said, and then she probed a little deeper. “When did Mrs. Manning finally realize you were her old friend ‘Falco Nipote’?”
A sudden, fleeting smile flickered in his golden eyes and touched the corners of his mouth, momentarily softening his features in a way that made Sam catch her breath at the transformation. “I evidently said something very funny just now?” she ventured, trying to maintain her calm, businesslike approach.
He inclined his head in a slow nod, traces of the smile still lingering in his eyes, but he remained frustratingly silent.
“Give me a break—” she joked before she could stop herself.
He thawed another degree at her joking plea and actually gave her that break. “Falco is Italian for ‘hawk,’ which was my nickname in the old days. That’s the name that Leigh heard me called.”
“And Nipote?” Sam pressed. “That’s Italian for—?”
“Nephew.”
Sam’s eyes widened in puzzlement. “That’s what we were told when we checked with people who are fluent in Italian, but we thought it must have some other meaning between you and Mrs. Manning. Why would she know you as ‘nephew’?” Sam realized the answer before she finished the question, but waited for him to confirm it.
“Leigh used to hear my aunt call me that, and she assumed it was my name.”
“You didn’t know each other well at all then?”
“We rarely spoke.”
“I see.” Sam remembered the important question that had started her down this surprising path, but which still remained unanswered. “When did Mrs. Manning realize that you were her old friend from Great Jones Street?” she asked as the car pulled over to the curb just past the corner at Park Avenue and Forty-eighth Street.
“The same night she learned her husband was dead. I had gone to see her specifically to tell her who I was, and to see how she was doing.”
“Were you still with her when we talked to her that night?” Sam asked as the chauffeur got out and opened the back door of the limo. Her fragile truce with him collapsed the instant she asked that question, because he realized she was no longer playing completely straight with him.
“You know damned well I was,” he retorted, then he nodded curtly to the open car door and said brusquely, “This is where we get out.”
With no choice except to get out, too, Sam did so, and both men followed her onto the sidewalk, leaving her there. Valente paused to say something to his driver and then strode off with Buchanan, both of them with briefcases in hand. Sam walked to the rear of the limo, her arms clasped around her, craning her neck for a cab; then she turned around to see where Valente and Buchanan were headed. She had no coat and no purse, ergo, no money for a taxi, but she could pay for one when she got back to the precinct.
Valente and Buchanan walked into the huge building that took up the whole block, and, on an impulse, Sam decided to follow them. “Where are you going, miss?” Valente’s chauffeur called out as she ran past him. “Mr. Valente told me to take you back to the precinct—”
“Wait here or circle the block,” Sam called to him. “I forgot to ask him something,” she lied.
She dashed into the building just as the elevator doors closed behind Valente and his attorney. Backing up, Sam watched the lights above the elevator flash as it passed the floors, then glow a steady green on the sixteenth floor.
The building’s directory was located between the elevators, and she scanned the names listed on it with suites on the sixteenth floor. There were only four names shown, which indicated they were very large suites. “Knightsbridge Obstetrics and Gynecology”; “Truman and Horn, Certified Public Accountants”; “Aldenberry, Smith, and Cromwell,” a very well known law firm. Sam ruled out the obstetricians with an inner laugh. When Valente and McCord had been together in the interviewing room earlier, the atmosphere had been positively crackling with macho, killer-instinct, maleness. Definitely not the obstetricians. Valente’s cousin handled his financial matters, and Valente was already represented by one of the most prestigious law firms in New York, so she ruled the other two firms out. The fourth suite of offices on the sixteenth floor belonged to a company called Interquest Inc.
Sam went to the reception desk, pointed to the ID badge hanging from a chain around her neck, and spoke to the guard. “What can you tell me about Interquest?”
“Not a whole lot, Detective. About all I know is they’re a private investigation firm on the sixteenth floor, and they must be expensive as hell, because they’ve got a suite of offices up there you wouldn’t believe.”
“Thank you very much,” she replied, glancing at his name tag, “Leon.”
LOST IN THOUGHT, Sam gazed out the window of Valente’s limousine at the tide of pedestrians hurrying past on the sidewalk, their heads bent into the wind as they outpaced the snarl of lunchtime traffic.
Since Valente and Buchanan had requested a meeting at the precinct to discuss Manning’s murder, and then gone directly to a private investigation firm, Sam had a strong hunch that Valente had hired his own investigators to try to find Logan Manning’s murderer. A very odd thing for a man to do if he thought the woman he was in love with had done the deed. Either that, or Valente’s lawyer was looking for viable, alternative suspects to throw at McCord like decoys now—or to bring up in court later in order to confuse a jury into believing there were other people besides Mrs. Manning with a motive and opportunity to kill Logan Manning.
That, of course, assumed that Valente’s alibis checked out and removed him from the list of suspects. Even if they did check out, there was also the possibility that Valente had paid someone else to murder Manning.
Sam sighed. That was all perfectly possible and even believable. What wasn’t believable was that Valente had actually bothered to send her back in his nice, warm limousine.
On the sixteenth floor, Michael stood at the window, idly watching his car inching through traffic with Sam Littleton in it. “Littleton followed us into the building,” he remarked to Buchanan.
The founder of Interquest, Stephen Wallbrecht, walked into his office and heard Michael’s remark. “Samantha K. Littleton—” he provided, “the youngest and most inexperienced member of the team investigating Manning’s murder.”
Chapter 57
* * *
A subtly dynamic man, Wallbrecht was tall and slender, with thinning hair, keenly intelligent light gray eyes, and an aura of absolute competence and relentless energy.
“Sorry to keep you waiting, Michael,” he said, shaking hands with him and then Buchanan. He sat down behind his desk and removed some files from his bottom right-hand drawer. “As usual, I’d like to start by quickly evaluating our adversaries.” While he spoke he handed both men a set