"The others are dead. The ones you saw killed were the real people. The duplicates, the robots, stood by and watched."
Garrett said nothing.
"Now you're supposed to say, 'For the love of God, Montresor!'" said Stendahl. "And I will reply, 'Yes, for the love of God.' Won't you say it? Come on. Say it."
"You fool."
"Must I coax you? Say it. Say 'For the love of God, Montresor!'"
"I won't, you idiot. Get me out of here." He was sober now.
"Here. Put this on." Stendahl tossed in something that belled and rang.
"What is it?"
"A cap and bells. Put it on and I might let you out."
"Stendahl!"
"Put it on, I said!"
Garrett obeyed. The bells tinkled.
"Don't you have a feeling that this has all happened before?" inquired Stendahl, setting to work with trowel and mortar and brick now.
"What're you doing?"
"Walling you in. Here's one row. Here's another."
"You're insane!"
"I won't argue that point."
"You'll be prosecuted for this!"
He tapped a brick and placed it on the wet mortar, humming.
Now there was a thrashing and pounding and a crying out from within the darkening place. The bricks rose higher. "More thrashing, please," said Stendahl. "Let's make it a good show."
"Let me out, let me out!"
There was one last brick to shove into place. The screaming was continuous.
"Garrett?" called Stendahl softly. Garrett silenced himself. "Garrett," said Stendahl, "do you know why I've done this to you? Because you burned Mr. Poe's books without really reading them. You took other people's advice that they needed burning. Otherwise you'd have realized what I was going to do to you when we came down here a moment ago. Ignorance is fatal, Mr. Garrett."
Garrett was silent.
"I want this to be perfect," said Stendahl, holding his lantern up so its light penetrated in upon the slumped figure. "Jingle your bells softly." The bells rustled. "Now, if you'll please say, 'For the love of God, Monstresor,' I might let you free."
The man's face came up in the light. There was a hesitation. Then grotesquely the man said, "For the love of God, Montresor."
"Ah," said Stendahl, eyes closed. He shoved the last brick into place and mortared it tight. "Requiescat in pace, dear friend."
He hastened from the catacomb.
In the seven rooms the sound of a midnight clock brought everything to a halt.
The Red Death appeared.