Kady’s mouth fell open.
“Of course she’s telling the truth,” Penny said. “Why would she lie?”
I felt weird, standing in the middle of the kitchen with the three of them practically in my face and grilling me. They weren’t being mean, but inquisitive, how I assumed sisters were supposed to be.
“Can I get some coffee?” I asked, deflecting.
Penny, who seemed to be a people pleaser more than the others, went to get me a mug. Kady eyed me, trying to decide if I’d lied or not. Cricket just shook her head and rolled her eyes.
“I’ve been in love with Wilder and King for years. Since I was thirteen. That’s really weird, being so young and all, so I just let it alone until we dated last summer.” I shrugged. “It didn’t really work out, but I saw them again last night. Things just…clicked. Still, it’s crazy to get engaged after less than twenty-four hours.”
“Crazy? We’re all crazy,” Penny said, pointing her finger between the three of them. “Cricket had a one-night-stand which turned into a weekend with three guys, one of them ending up being Sutton who worked here at Steele Ranch which she coincidentally inherited. Kady slept with her men within hours of arriving in Montana.”
“On the front porch,” Kady added, clearly proud of that.
“And I dropped my virginity like a prom dress,” Penny offered. “Trust me, you’re a Steele sister.”
“You could have told us who you were and we’d have kept it a secret,” Kady said.
“Ha!” Cricket and Penny both shouted at the same time, as if that would have been impossible.
Penny looked to me. “Whatever the start with Wilder and King, now you’re getting married. It’s really romantic,” she said, handing me a steaming mug. I was glad she changed the subject. “Sugar or milk?”
“Milk, please.”
“I’ll get it,” Cricket said. “Go lean against the counter or something before Jamison comes in and makes you go sit down.” She pointed at Kady. “You, too. I swear, overprotective men are why I’m staying on the pill.”
Knowing she was right, Kady and Penny went to get stools from the kitchen’s peninsula and sat down, leaning their elbows back on the counter behind them to give their bellies room.
Cricket brought me a small carton of milk and I poured some into my mug, then handed it back.
“You two must have gotten pregnant right away,” I guessed since they’d only come to Barlow last summer.
“Pretty fast,” Kady said.
“The first time,” Penny shared.
The first time. That would be tomorrow for me. Good thing I had an IUD or I’d probably be pregnant right away myself. No doubt Wilder and King would be virile and attentive. And since King had said they were going to fill me with so much cum it would drip out of me all week, they’d ensure it happened.
“I’m impressed you’ve saved yourself for marriage. It’s going to make tomorrow really s
pecial,” Penny said.
“You got married right away, too?” I asked, seeing the beautiful ring on her finger.
She smiled. “Oh no. Long story, but I had lost my virginity the first night we got together. But I’d saved myself, although it wasn’t like I knew them all my life like you and Wilder and King. It just worked out that way. I’m glad now.”
I nodded, understanding. “Exactly. There just hasn’t been anyone I’ve wanted besides Wilder and King. So it never happened.” I left out that I liked kink, liked submission. They might know I got off in the laundry room, but the butt plug, the spankings weren’t being shared. “And it’s not me who wants to wait to have sex. It’s them. I had my hands on their belt buckles, eager, but they refuse to take their pants off until I’m theirs.” I held up my left hand, wiggled my bare ring finger.
King came in, grabbed my coffee and took a sip. “Everything okay?” he asked, his blue eyes studying me closely.
I bit my lip, nodded. He kissed my forehead, then left.
We burst out laughing.
“I can only imagine what’s beneath those pants,” Cricket said, her eyes alight with humor.
Penny smacked her arm. “Says the woman who has three dicks of her own.”