She tenses slightly as I slide a finger through the tight ring of muscles, groaning at the way they cling to me.
My cock is leaking onto the floor as I thrust my finger in and out of her tight hole.
“It’s going to take a while to stretch your tight little ass.” I spank her ass cheek with my free hand. “Do you have any lube?”
Nat glances at me over her shoulder and nods. “There’s some in the bathroom cabinet.”
I narrow my eyes, suspicious as to why she has any at all. After all, she was a virgin when I had her. “What do you use it for?”
Her cheeks turn a bright red as she swallows hard. “Curiosity. I have a dildo and used it a few times in my ass.”
I groan at the mental picture she just painted for me. “Where is the dildo?”
“With the lube,” she says.
I walk into the bathroom and open the cabinet, rooting around to find both the dildo and the lube. Once I find it, I return to find her in the exact same position.
She hasn’t moved a muscle.
“I’m going to fuck your ass with this dildo first. Make sure it’s nice and stretched and ready for my cock.”
She looks at me over her shoulder and licks her lip. “It’s a lot smaller than your cock. Are you sure it will fit?”
I jerk myself off and nod. “I’ll make it fit, and you are going to fucking love every second of it.” I pour lube onto her tight hole and work two fingers in first, slowly stretching the muscles. After adding a third finger, Natalya is moaning and panting like the dirty little girl she is.
“That’s right, moan while I finger your tight little ass.”
She arches her back and I spank her ass cheeks, which results in a ball-tightening whimper. “Elias, please.”
I smirk. “Please what?”
“Please give me more.”
I can feel what little control of myself I have slipping as I pump my fingers harder into her ass, making her moan.
And then I pull them out, grabbing the dildo and pouring lube all over it. “Let’s see how well you take this.” I push it through her tight sphincter and it clings to the rubber like a second skin.
Finally, her muscles relent and the dildo pops through, sliding all the way inside her ass.
“Oh God,” she moans, glancing at me over her shoulder. “I don’t think I can take your cock.”
“You’ll take what I give you like a good little whore, do you understand?”
Her teeth sink into her bottom lip as she nods.
“My good little whore.”
She moans, eyes flickering shut. “Yes, master.”
I groan and pump the dildo in and out of her ass, watching in awe at the way her muscle clings to it.
I’ve never seen something so fucking perfect in all my life, and I know when my cock sinks inside her virgin ass for the first time it will be utter heaven.
As I fuck her hard, her pussy gets wetter, making a mess of the comforter below.
“You are loving this, aren’t you?”
“Yes, it feels so fucking good.”