“So, it’s not that you are worried about Tiana using the title and you being in that role. No. You think you’ll naturally succeed at it and for some reason that scares you more than failing.”
“Yes, Sir.”
“You can be her Dom without becoming her daddy,” Tanner stated as if I’d never thought of that.
“She needs a daddy,” I replied as if it was the most obvious decree in the world. “Tiana was practically screaming for one when I knew her. I’m sure that need is even bigger since enduring whatever the hell she went through in California.”
Tanner had shared the limited info he knew, gleaned from Tate and Tiana, but it didn’t paint the entire picture.
“Jesse and I used to tame her sass all over campus, but it’s been a hot minute.” Tanner kissed me again. “You up for a challenge? Because I think you’re spot on. Tiana doesn’t need just one daddy, she needs two.”
Something about the way he looked at me coupled with the statement that came out of his mouth, filled me with a mixture of warmth and confidence. He believed in my ability to handle Tiana, trusted me, which stroked my ego in a good way. “I love you.”
“I love you, rebel. Is that a yes?”
“Yeah, hotshot. I’m up for it.”
“Title.” Tanner threaded his fingers against my scalp, tugging me upward. I had almost cut my hair right before I met him, but moments like this made me happy for the length. I fucking loved the sharp bite of pain knowing he could lead me wherever he wanted me.
“I’m up for it, Sir.”
“Good. Do you want Daddy to suck you off or fuck you?”
That was not a fair choice. As much as I loved the feeling of Tanner filling me up, something I hadn’t experienced much before him, I was addicted to his blow jobs. There was something about watching a man who literally put his life on the line every single day for the benefit of others, jacked out with muscles and a few well-placed tattoos, the greenest eyes in all of Wyoming, and with the most loving heart I’d ever know, going down on my dick like he owned it. Well, he did own it. He made that clear when we got into a relationship.
Studying his handsome features, I blew out a breath. “I don’t know.”
“It’s that hard of a choice, huh?” Tanner gave me a cocky grin. “All right. I’ll flip a coin.”
“Daddy...” I started to protest, but he held up a finger. It was his way of counting down without saying numbers out loud. I slammed my mouth shut. I did not need our time together to be spent with him punishing me.
“You had your chance.” He walked over to the dresser and scanned for the money bowl we kept there. Plucking a half dollar from it, he spun it through his fingers.
“I don’t think you can do a proper heads or tails with a coin that big.” I rolled my eyes.
“I’ll make it work.” Tanner returned to my side. “Heads I go down on you. Tails?” He chuckled darkly, a sound that instantly aroused me. I grew hard, staring up at him. “Well, tails means I turn you around and claim your ass.”
“I’ll pick.”
“Not anymore you won’t.” He flipped the coin. I swallowed the anticipation causing a flutter of emotion to flash through me as if we hadn’t done both options before. Something about his tone, his handling, all of it left me floundering. Tanner slapped his hand over it, and peeked. “Lucky you. It’s heads.”
“I’m always lucky when I’m with you, Sir.”
“You’re so fucking cute, rebel.” He winked before pulling me to the edge of the mattress. Kneeling in between my legs, he leaned his hands on my upper thighs while he got into a comfortable position. Watching him aroused me as much as his handling of me had. It was sexy when any partner arranged themselves on their knees but having your Dom do it brought another level of heat. Stroking his hand along the shaft of my cock, he took the head in between his lips.
“Oh, Sir.” He had barely started and I was already done for. Running my hand through his hair, I let my head fall back on my shoulders. “You feel so good.”
Tanner took me deeper into his mouth, sucking on my dick with a mix of rough and gentle motions. I imagined for a moment what it might be like for me to give him a blowjob while Tiana had me in between her sexy lips. More mental images of the three of us taking turns with each other flitted through my brain. I could barely concentrate on the pleasure happening to me while my mind raced.
Raising my head, I voiced the fantasy to him wondering where he might be regarding a threesome. We’d engaged in a few over the past few years but they had all been missing something. “Can we both fuck Tia at the same time?”
Slipping my rock hard dick out of his mouth, Tanner raised an eyebrow. “Is that what you want to do?”
“I can’t stop thinking about it.”
“Let’s get her to agree to a relationship first, rebel. Everything else will follow.” Keeping his eyes on me, he rubbed his hand up and down. “What do you say?”
“Yes, Sir.”