“But—”
“If I were you, baby, I’d get my clothes off and get on the bed. You’re already going to get punished. Do you want to make it worse?”
She felt her limbs shake. He’d never really punished her, so she didn’t know how bad it could be. Instead of pushing him further, she started to undress. When she was done, she crawled up onto the bed, sat back on her heels, and waited.
After undressing, he walked over and got a condom and lube out of the nightstand.
“Lie down,” he said.
Since he got the lube out, she assumed he would buttfuck her, so she rolled onto her stomach.
“No, stay on your back. I’m going to take your ass this way because I want to see your expressions.”
She lay flat and looked up at him while he got ready. Rolling on the condom and making sure it was generously covered with lube. He pulled her to the edge of the mattress and looped his arms under her knees to hold her legs up and out.
She started to squirm when she felt his fingers glide into her cunt several times to make sure she was ready before he lined his cock up and started to press into her ass.
It felt different this way. A little tighter and more intense with the angle it slid into her.
“That’s it, take my cock, baby.”
Holly grabbed the blanket under her and tried to relax as the stinging worsened. The breath whooshed out of her lungs when he finally made it through the muscle.
“That’s right. Take all of it.”
She cried out when he finally bottomed out inside of her.
“That’s a good girl.”
She nodded and tried to get him to move. “Daddy.”
He stayed still and looked down at her. “Who were you calling?”
Her eyes widened, and she started to buck.
He put a stop to that by ramming into her a few times and then stopping again.
“Who were you calling, baby? I can stay like this for the rest of the day if I have to.”
Holly felt her eyes burn with tears. “My mother.”
“Good girl. Now, tell me why,” Jonah said.
She stiffened again, making him thrust into her, which built her desire up to aching levels. “I was asking her if Caylee and I could come and stay with her.”
“Where does she live?” he asked.
“Venice.”
“Across an ocean. Why?”
She bit her lip and shook her head.
He studied her for a moment. “Do you not want to be with me any longer? Do you want to get away from me that badly?”
Her mouth dropped open. “God, no. If I had a choice, I’d never leave you. It’s just that Caylee and I were talking, and the idea that you guys could get hurt made us sick. We’d do anything to keep you safe.”
“Isn’t it the daddy’s job to protect his baby?” Jonah asked.