They all laughed.
‘Well that explains it,’ Shay said. ‘Worked well, though.’
‘Means a lot coming from you,’ Conor replied.
‘Hey, Shay,’ Finn said, taking hold of Tammy’s other hand, ‘the three of us wanted to speak to you about something.’
‘We’ve missed you, Shay,’ said Conor. ‘All of us.’
Tammy was looking coy. She kept looking down.
‘I missed you all too,’ Shay admitted.
‘Ever since you called and filled us in on what happened with Tammy’s dad, the wound that was opened when we abandoned Tammy all those years ago was finally healed.’
Shay nodded. There were no secrets anymore. There was nothing to keep them apart.
‘And ever since we rescued Tammy,’ Finn continued, ‘it’s like the four of us have been a unit. A real team.’
This was the moment. The moment they told Shay they loved him, and that he could be Tammy’s friend again. ‘Sure. It feels good.’
‘You know that we want to be Tammy’s Daddies. Heck, you helped us realize that we needed a contract, to make things safe and official. Thing is, it feels like, to us, you’re Tammy’s Daddy, too.’
Shay’s heart leaped in his chest. He tapped his foot, trying to work off some of his nervous energy.
‘You’ve been looking after me for years, just the way a Daddy should,’ Tammy said, more confident now.
‘We talked today, while you were on Splash Mountain.’
Sothat’swhy they’d insisted he go on the ride by himself. At the time, Shay had struggled to understand why they kept pushing him to have some alone time. He’d assumed that they’d wanted to kiss and canoodle together. Turns out, he was wrong.
‘What did you talk about?’ Shay asked, feeling like he was on the edge of a precipice.
‘We’re going to claim our Little Girl tonight,’ Conor said matter-of-factly. Shay felt a thrill of excitement. He’d never been involved in a discussion like this before, even though he’d longed to.
‘But we want to do it right,’ Finn replied.
‘So, do you want to make it right with us?’ Conor asked. ‘Do you want to share with us, Shay?’
Shay looked at Tammy. He didn’t say anything, but it was as though he was asking her a question.
Is this what you really want, Tammy? Am I good enough for you?
Without missing a beat, she nodded.
Shay breathed in deep, let out a slow breath. Then, he spoke. ‘You bet I do.’
CHAPTER 17
Through the glass floor, the teal ocean swirled and lapped, illuminated by lights hidden beneath the rim of the bungalow.
Tammy kneeled on the smooth glass, watching the shapes of the sea, breathing steadily, waiting impatiently. She looked down at her naked body, noticing that she was trembling slightly. Her nipples were dark against her pale skin. A lick of blond pubic hair curled up from between her legs, reaching toward the smooth plane of her stomach.
As she shifted gently from side to side, she could feel the plug in her butt. The brothers had put it in together — Shay applying the lube, Conor positioning the plug, and Finn finally pushing the smooth tip deep into her willing entrance.
Tammy had never used a butt plug before. It didn’t feel unpleasant — quite the opposite, in fact. She could feel the pressure on her pussy too, from the inside out. It was having a profound effect on her — she could feel the lust moistening her, making her desperate to touch herself. If only the brothers hadn’t forbidden her from doing that very thing.
She’d only been like this for a few minutes, but the wait was killing her. She wondered what the boys had planned. Were they going to come in one by one? Would they be naked? What would they do to her?