“You little minx. You knew exactly what you were doing. Maybe I’ll fuck your ass after all as a punishment for not telling us the truth sooner.”
“No, I’m not ready for that…”
“All right, another time then.” I grin suggestively.
For now, I use my thumb, circling her swollen clit until she sighs and spreads her legs further. I can smell her heat mixed with my brother’s cum, and the combination has me close to losing control. I could take my cock in my fist, and it wouldn’t be more than a few strokes before I’d come across her stomach and tits.
Instead, I plunge into her dripping hole again. She whimpers, rolling her hips in circles so every inch of her tight channel hits every inch of me. For somebody new to this, she’s catching on quick. Letting her body take the reins and tell her what it needs.
“Dirty girl,” I growl, still teasing her clit, slowly fucking her. It’s beyond anything I’ve ever seen before. Watching this perfect, beautiful thing open up under me. Watching her body wake up, feeling it from the inside. The way her muscles quiver and twitch and make room for me as I stretch her like she’s never been stretched before.
She turns her face away like she’s embarrassed when really, it was a compliment. “Look at me.” There’s no room for protest when I command a woman like that, and she’s no different. Her eyes meet mine, and the light in them does something to me. It touches a part of me I didn’t know existed. All I can do is slide in and out in slow, controlled strokes while the friction of my thumb on her bundle of nerves makes her tighten around me until it almost hurts.
“That’s right.” I stroke faster, letting myself get closer as she reaches the end. “Come on my cock, baby. Show me how much you love being used like a fucking slut.”
She tenses, back arching and eyes squeezing shut before letting out an ear-piercing scream. The last thing I see before closing my eyes and shooting cum deep inside her is the flush that comes over her skin just before she starts milking me dry. I don’t think I’ve ever come so hard in my life, and by the time I’m finished, I want to collapse and sleep for a year.
Instead, Kane frees Payton, and I go to the bathroom for washcloths and towels. When I come back, my brother and I clean her up—gently, tenderly, keeping in mind how sore she has to be after taking the two of us. Her first time, and she ended up getting fucked by two men with, if I do say so myself, huge cocks.
“I’m sorry.” Kane doesn’t use those words lightly or often.
“So am I,” I agree as I wipe away the blood on the insides of her thighs. She tenses a little, but I shush her, wiping even more gently than before until she’s clean. “We didn’t know. We had to assume the worst.”
“You believe me now?” She chews her lip, looking back and forth between us. “For real?”
“If we didn’t, this would’ve ended a lot differently.” She flinches, and I know it’s not because of anything we’re doing to her body.
It makes me feel around two inches tall, to be honest. I’d never admit it out loud, not even to Kane, but it’s the truth. We hurt her and would’ve done worse than hurt her if she hadn’t given us the answers we wanted. If she had held out and refused to admit the truth, which I guess she’s ashamed of but is much, much less than what either of us expected.
“And you don’t think there’s something wrong with me? Now that you know why I have to use this name?”
Kane bursts out laughing. “Are you serious? It makes you cooler.”
“Think about who you’re talking to.” She giggles when I say it, and I have to laugh, too. Accomplice to a robbery. Kid stuff.
The laughter doesn’t make me feel much better, though. I hate myself for how close we came to wrecking her forever. She’s just as innocent as we first thought. Not everybody has two sides to them. Not everybody’s out to get us.
Some people really do need help, and that’s it.
I lean in, letting my lips brush against her ear while helping her sit up. “I’m sorry for not trusting you,” I murmur, “and I promise I’ll make it up to you somehow. If there’s one thing I have going for me, it’s my word. I never break a promise.”