***Reagan***
Inoddedandstroked his hair out of his face, happy to slip out of our game and into something more personal. I wrapped my arms around his neck and kissed him again as he walked us towards the bed. He undressed us both and then settled on the bed with me under him, my thighs spread around his.
“I’ve wanted to feel you around me for a very long time, Rea. The fact that we’ve had sex twice before and I’d never been inside you is criminal.” He brushed my hair out of my face and kissed me as he slowly pushed his length into me.
I broke the kiss and moaned as he stretched me and filled me perfectly. I squeezed my thighs around his waist and watched his face twist in pleasure as he finally seated his entire length in me. My heart raced wildly as his bedroom eyes met mine and rolled shut.
“Fucking hell.” Theo braced himself with one arm beside my head and reached down to grip my ass with the other. “I can promise you that if I’d felt your magical pussy milking my cock when I was eighteen, I would’ve stalked you across the country. Don’t move a muscle, Rea.”
I pushed up on my elbows to kiss him and then looked down at where our bodies were joined. The sight of my lower lips stretched open around his engorged cock made me moan and squeeze my walls tighter, apparently, as Theo cursed.
“That’s moving a muscle. Do you work out? With just your—”
“No!” I laughed and then decided to tease him. “Theo, are you going to fuck me? All these men are watching and I’m sure if you need a minute, one of them would step in.”
His face hardened and he clicked his tongue at me. “Watch that tongue, Rea. I know a few men who’d love to help keep you quiet if we need it.”
My body responded to the idea, knowing that he meant Charlie and August. When Theo’s lips quirked up, revealing he was all but reading my mind, I blushed. “Shut up.”
He went up on his knees and pulled me with him so my hips were raised and my top half was still flat on the bed, staring up at him. In that position, he felt even bigger and deeper. His eyes focused on my core as he slowly withdrew his cock and then pushed back in just as slowly. His hand rested just over my sex with his thumb lightly bumping into my clit. He kept up his slow pace for almost two whole minutes before I snapped.
“Dammit, Theo, fuck me!”
His wicked grin told me that he’d been waiting for me to break. He widened his knees and pulled my legs up his chest, so my ankles hung by his head. My own knees pressed into my chest as he folded himself over me, bending me how he wanted me. I almost shouted when he pulled out just as slowly, but the words were stolen from my mouth when he thrust into me fast and hard, hitting deep and jarring my entire body up the bed.
I grabbed his arms where they were braced on the bed around me and opened my mouth in a silent scream as he set a brutal pace, pounding his shaft into me. Theo watched my face, his own twisted in pleasure.
“Fucking beautiful.” His voice was pure gravel as he slammed in and out of me. He shifted, grabbing both of my breasts and squeezing before pulling out and flipping me over. “Grab the headboard and don’t let go.”
I did as he said, gripping his wooden headboard for dear life and moaned when I felt his mouth on me. His tongue worked my clit hungrily before he moved and drove his cock back into me. The new angle had him rubbing my g-spot with every thrust and I knew that I wasn’t going to last long.
Theo gripped my hips hard and trailed his mouth up my spine and over my shoulder. “Give me your mouth.”
I turned my head and kissed him, delirious as one of his hands moved around to cup my sex. His fingers rubbed and patted my clit in time with his hard thrusts. I moaned helplessly into his mouth, so close to coming that my thighs shook.
He pulled back enough to watch my face. “Where do you want me to come, Rea? In this sweet pussy or in your hot little mouth?”
Pressure built in my core as my limbs stiffened. The feeling of his thighs slapping against mine, his stomach on my back, the sound of his cock fucking me, it was all so dirty. I couldn’t speak, couldn’t function as my orgasm grew closer, so close it hurt.
Theo wrapped his hand around my neck from behind and pushed my head lower, using the leverage to pound into me even harder and faster. His fingers slapped my clit once more and when I let out a wild scream, he growled and raked his teeth over my shoulder. “Too late, baby. I couldn’t pull out if I wanted to. Your walls are squeezing me so good. I’m going to fuck my come right into you, Rea. Tell me you want my come in your pussy. Say it.”
As my orgasm slammed into me, I threw my head back and screamed for him. “I want your come in my pussy, Theo!”
His big hand slapped my ass hard once before he let out a feral sound and came like a fire hose. His hot seed filled me and leaked out around us, even as my orgasm milked more out of him. My body pulsed and shook as pleasure washed over me in strong waves that didn’t feel like they’d ever stop. I lost myself in the feeling of it and collapsed to the bed, still riding out one of the best orgasms I’d ever had.
Theo followed me down and wrapped me in his arms, holding me tight as his seed leaked out and made a mess of his bed and both of our bodies. He ignored it and pressed open mouthed kisses all over my neck and shoulders, focusing on one area that felt bruised.
“I’m sorry, baby. I was rough with you.” He stroked my hair and down my side, touching certain spots more as he went. I noticed later they were spots that bore red marks and bruises from his hands.
My face was buried in a pillow that smelled strongly like him, a pillow I didn’t want to leave, but I forced my face up and tried to speak, but my voice was hoarse from all the screaming. I cleared my throat and tried again. “I’m really glad you don’t have neighbors.”
He rolled me into his chest so he could see my face. “Are you okay?”
“I think I’m dead.” I saw the worry on his face and smiled what I knew was a goofy smile. “Don’t worry. It was a great way to go.”
“What I said about stalking you before?”
I nodded absently, so relaxed and limp that I could barely keep my eyes open. “Yeah?”
“I’m going to need you to stay in the New Mexico area. It’ll be awfully hard to stalk you if you move out of state now that I have Iris.” He pressed gentle kisses to my forehead and held me tighter to his chest. “You can sleep, Rea. There’s no way I’m letting you go tonight.”
I curled my thigh over his and mumbled. “Should shower.”
“Sleep, baby. We’ll clean you up later.”
Unfortunately, when the sun rose and someone pounded on the door before letting themselves in, I was still just as filthy as when I’d passed out, with Theo plastered to me in every way.