Anna quietly shook her head at us, and suddenly, I could see her eyes sparkling with the same sort of hunger I'd seen in them before on that night she watched us.
Tyler suddenly leaned forward and growled into my ear. "I need to fuck you, now." His lips sucked at my earlobe for a moment, and I felt myself shudder on top of him as Anna watched.
"Should we go?" I said it to both of them, sort of, and I felt Tyler nod as I watched Anna do the same. Slowly, and as inconspicuously as possible, I bit my lip and slid off of his throbbing cock, a little gasp tumbling from my mouth as he slipped out of my folds beneath my skirt.
I sat back in the booth, feeling my face glow red as I smoothed my skirt and as Tyler tucked himself back into his pants. I turned to see Anna grinning at me, making my stomach flutter.
*****
The winter air felt soothing against my burning cheeks with my pulse racing like it was when we stepped outside to hail a cab. I was still so turned on and practically buzzing as Tyler nuzzled my neck while he scanned the street for a cab.
"Ooooo-kay, well, you two look like you've got plans for the rest of the night, so I'm just going to go,” Anna winked and grinned at me jokingly, but her eyes still had that hungry, burning look in them as they seared into my own.
I could feel that same naughty urge bubbling to the surface again, like before when I'd seen her watching us. And just like then, I could feel my pulse skip a beat as I thought about her eyes on us. Again, I didn't know what it was, but I was realizing more and more how much it turned me on to be watched, specifically by her.
I knew right then what I wanted, even as I felt my head spinning trying to make sense of it. I turned and looked up into Tyler’s eyes, asking without saying a word and feeling my whole body glow.
His eyes suddenly went wide as he read the unspoken look in mine. "Really?"
I nodded slow, biting my lip and feeling my breath catch in my throat. "It- it'd be pretty hot.” I swallowed thickly. “Watching only, again. No touching,” I added quickly.
Tyler’s face went dark with a wolfish look as his eyes pierced into mine. “Only if it's okay with you, baby.”
I leaned and kissed him quickly, putting all my passion into it as I pressed my lips to his, before I turned around. My pulse was racing, and I know my face was burning bright red as I looked deep into Anna’s eyes. "Do- do you want to come?"
Chapter 23
Christina
The cab ride was tense and heavy with excitement. None of us spoke a word, but I knew all three of us were practically bubbling with energy with the sexual energy palpable in the backseat.
"It was me, in the shower today." Anna’s voice was small next to me, a whisper in the dark of the cab.
I gasped what she was saying suddenly and whirled to her, my jaw dropping. “You mean-”
“Yeah,” she grinned, smirking at me before looking past me at Tyler on the other side of the backseat. "You two are hot, you know."
*****
If Tyler got looks walking through that hotel lobby before with just me before, he was downright scandalous with two teenage girls hanging off his arms. We rode the elevator up in silence, trying not to giggle at the middle-aged couple raising their eyebrows at him and shaking their heads like he was some sort of predator before they stepped off at the floor below ours.
Oh if you only knew, I thought, thinking about how I'd been the seducer when it came to him and I.
In the room, the excitement turned to giddy nervousnesses. Anna had after all seen us have sex before, but it had been such a spur of the moment thing. Seeing her spying on us before had gotten me so hot that I'd just kept doing what we'd been doing, only then with her openly in the room. This time though, we were going to begin with her there too, and I felt a shiver of nervous energy ripple through me.
"Just looking,” I said it more forcefully than I meant to at Anna while Tyler was in the bathroom washing his hands. Instantly I winced and backtracked. "Sorry, I just- I mean, just, you know, no touching.”
“Chris,” Anna stepped closer to me. “I get it, really.” She took a shaky breath. “Are you sure you wa
nt to do thi-”
"I'm sure." Our eyes met and I grinned at her. “Are you?”
She giggled nervously. “I think?”
I reached out and took her hand in mine. “I love you, you know, and I want to share this with you.” I felt my cheeks go bright red. "Also, its- well, it's kind of hot with you watching.”
She grinned. “Tell me about it.” We giggled and she grabbed me into a hug. “And thank you,” she whispered. “Thanks for letting me be a part of…well, this, I guess.”