Nodding at Marshall, Pops waited for the other man to pull out. He stayed perfectly still within her, holding. When Marshall started to thrust back inside, he worked his cock out of her. They built up a steady pace, where they took turns fucking inside her, stretching her.
Ethan teased her clit until she came all over Marshall’s cock, her ass also tightening around him.
Pops knew he wasn’t going to last. She wrapped one arm behind her, around his neck, as he rode her ass hard.
“I love you, Rosie, fucking love you,” he said, grinding into her ass one final time, and filing the condom with his cum. He moved out of her, and lay on the bed close to her as Gavin moved from her mouth, taking her ass himself. Marshall came, and they changed places. Gavin sat on the bed still in her ass, and now Billy moved inside her pussy.
“Perfect, baby, you’re fucking perfect,” Marshall said. “Never doubt that we want you. We all want you.”
Pops stroked her body, as did Marshall and Ethan, as Gavin and Billy found their release. Finally, Ethan moved between her thighs, and licking her cunt into another orgasm. Afterward, in the afterglow of sex, Rosie lay in the middle as they all surrounded her.
“What are you thinking?” he asked.
“That I’m the luckiest woman in the world.”
“Why do you think that?” he asked.
“Not only do I love five men, but five men also love me. Tell me how that can’t be lucky?” she asked, smiling. She cupped his cheek. “I really do love you. I love all of you.”
“Forever,” Pops said.
“The only way I’m leaving is if the angels take me,” Marshall said. “This is what I’ve been wanting all my life. You, us, a family. This is what I consider to be the best life of all.”
“It’s not going to be easy,” Gavin said. “Some folks in town won’t like it.”
“Everyone can fuck off,” Ethan said. “No one will say shit to any of us, and if they try, we’ll show them we mean business.”
She giggled. “You’ll protect me?”
“Forever.”
“The moment you walked into the bar, Rosie, you became ours,” Pops said. He pressed a kiss to her lips. “There’s no way we’re letting you go.”
“We’ll have you barefoot and pregnant in no time,” Billy said, making it sound more like a promise.
She sighed. “I can’t wait.”