“If I don’t will you send me away?” Stacie asked with tears in her eyes.
Seth held her tighter and answered. “We would never send you away. We just want you to explore this with us. If it isn’t something you want to do, we won’t force you. We all want you and want you to be happy with us. I understand you don’t like the idea of being punished. I don’t want to punish you, but I also don’t want you to put y
ourself in harm’s way again. If we spank you, then you will remember that next time you think about skipping a meal. Now, are you willing to try?
Stacie though a minute. Yes, this was something she wanted. She wanted more with these men. “I can use my safewords?”
“Yes, but if we think you are just using them to get out the the punishement we won’t be happy. Punishment is part of the lifestyle, and we want all of it not just the part that is fun.”
Stacie thought some more. She knew these men would never hurt her, and if she wanted to try this she needed to try it all not just part of it. Nodding her consent, she leaned into Seth’s chest. “Okay I’ll try, just go easy with me.”
Seth had planned to go easy all along. He knew how new she was to this. They would have to be careful, he had told his brothers when they talked about trying this with her.
Now Seth had had enough. “Time to get this over with, we’ve talked enough. Then we can go back to having fun,” he told her, standing her and undoing her robe.
“Stop overthinking this. It’s a spanking, nothing more,” Seth told her, pulling her naked form across his lap. It was going to be so much more than a spanking. She just didn’t know it yet. Positioning her so that she was ass-up across his lap, he placed one hand in the center of her back and used the other to start rubbing small circles over the cheeks of her bottom.
Seth kept rubbing, letting his hand drift lower and lower until it was trailing through the folds of her pussy before coming back to rub her cheeks.
Stacie started arching into his touch, craving more. With each pass he got closer and closer to her clit. Just before he started touching it, he stopped and announced, “We’re going to start now. You’ll get ten swats for this first time. Three from Grant, three from Jake, and four from me. Grant will start.”
Grant and Jake both got up from the couch and walked over to where Seth was holding Stacie. Jake walked around to her head and squatted in front of her, taking both her hands in his, giving Seth total control over her body. Her toes barely touched the floor, and without the use of her hands, she had no way to balance herself and had to trust Seth not to drop her.
Stacie struggled for a brief minute, but was afraid of falling. She could sense Grant’s presence behind her, but couldn’t turn her head enough to see what he was doing.
Grant was standing behind her and squeezing both her bottom cheeks, bringing blood to the surface of her skin. He and Jake would be using their hands, but when Seth took his turn, he would have a paddle.
Grant lifted his hand and made a nice print on her backside. Stacie gave a little cry but didn’t struggle. She was afraid of falling.
Jake held both of her hands in one of his and was watching her face. He cupped her cheek with his other hand and gently gave her a kiss of reassurance. “You’re doing fine, babe,” he told her quietly.
Seth had one hand holding her waist to anchor her on his lap and was using the other one to rub circles over her upper back and shoulders. Even though this was a punishment, they wanted her to enjoy it on some level.
Grant continued spanking her other cheek, and his last swat managed to hit both cheeks. As soon as he was finished, he lubed the small plug they had planned on using and slowly fed it into her small hole.
“Oh, what’s that?” she cried.
Jake was still in front of her and answered, “It’s just a small plug, babe, the one we told you about in the bedroom, now relax.”
Jake and Grant switched places and Jake pumped the plug in and out of her a few times, before reaching between her legs to feel the moisture there. He nodded to his brothers before giving her his three swats, then twisting the plug a few times.
Before Jake started his part of her punishement, Grant kissed her and asked, “Are you doing okay, baby? Do you want us to stop, or are you okay to continue?”
Stacie looked up at Grant and smiled. “I kind of like it,” she whispered.
“Okay, baby, Jake is going to take his turn, and then Seth will have his, okay?” Grant knew Stacie had whispered because she did want Jake or Seth hearing that she liked the spanking, but he couldn’t wait to tell them later.
Seth slipped his hand between her legs and rubbed her clit, while Jake ran up the stairs and came back with a paddle. They had a playroom in the barn, but it had been totally off-limits to Stacie. They all had a few toys stashed in their rooms and had brought a few toys in to play with her. They planned on taking her to the playroom soon if she responded like they hoped she would.
Stacie again tried to twist to see what was going on, but Grant held her face still with one hand, while holding her hands with the other. “Look at me, baby. Just focus on me.” He kissed her deeply, bringing her attention back to him.
Seth took the paddle. It was small and would sting nicely. Four would be enough to give her a reminder for a few hours, but not leave any bruises. Rubbing the paddle over her already-reddened skin, he got her used to the feel of it.
“What’s that? It feels different. It’s cold.” It wasn’t like their hands. This was something else.
Jake answered from beside her. “It’s a paddle, babe. Seth is giving you his four with it.”
Stacie was surprised at the response her body was having to what they were doing to her. She was producing a lot of moisture between her legs and her clit was throbbing. The tingling inside was intensifying with all they were doing to her, and she was afraid she was going to come.