I push more of my finger in before sliding it back out. With slow movements, I fuck his ass with my finger, watching the side of his face for his reaction. Reed and Rayn both must like what I’m doing because the noises they are making become louder and Reed’s thrusts pick up.
My cock turns painfully hard, the need to push it inside Reed is almost overwhelming.
He’s been fucked in the ass by guys before, so I know he can take me. Even so, I lean back to his ear. “You want my cock in your ass?” I ask.
His answer is immediate. “Fuck yes.”
“Don’t come yet,” I tell him, pushing my finger all the way inside and grinding my own cock against his ass cheek. “I want us all to come together. I can’t fucking wait to feel you squeezing my cock.”
“Shit,” he mumbles, his hips slowing. “Between Rayn’s tight grip on my dick and you talking about fucking my ass, I’m not sure how much longer I can hold back.” His head turns and his eyes meet mine. “Hurry the fuck up before I explode.”
I switch my gaze to Rayn, who looks like she’s on the verge of coming herself, and gently pull my finger from Reed’s ass. I leave the pair in the shower long enough to hunt down something to lube my cock with. The last thing I want to do is hurt Reed.
I find a bottle of unscented lotion under the sink and go back to the shower. Reed’s still slowly rocking his hips while his lips are fused with Rayn’s. I squirt some lotion on my hand and toss the bottle to the shower floor.
As I slide my hand up and down my shaft, getting it nice and slick so it easily slides inside Reed, I think about what I’m about to do. If someone told me a year ago that I would be preparing to fuck my male best friend, I probably would have knocked the fuck out of them. Never in a million years would I have thought I would be in the situation I’m in at the moment. Now that I am though, I can’t fucking wait to take his ass and make it mine. It surprises the hell out of me how much I want it. I want Reed as much as I want Rayn.
Lifting my eyes from Reed’s ass, my eyes once again connect with Rayn’s. She licks her lips, keeping them parted, and anticipation flares in her eyes.
Stepping up behind Reed, I drop my gaze as I grab one of his asscheeks and spread him open. I grip the base of my cock and angle the head just right. Nothing could force me to look away as I press the head against his tight puckered hole and watch as it slips inside.
“Holy fuck.” I almost choke on the words because he’s tighter than anything I’ve ever felt before. With just the head inside, I have to stop a moment because I’m on the edge of coming.
His asshole clenches around me, and whether or not he did it on purpose, it doesn’t help my precarious situation.
I grip his hips tightly. “Stop that shit,” I growl. “Or this will be over before it begins.”
“Then move,” he says back to me. “I can’t move until you do.”
Gritting my teeth and hoping I don’t make a fool of myself, I slide in another inch. I slide out and go back in even farther. I’ve still got a way to go to be fully inside him, and I have no fucking clue how I’ll be able to last.
“You guys have no damn clue how hot it is to see you like this.”
I look at Rayn, seeing her leaning her head back against the wall, her eyes half-closed and her cheeks rosy with arousal.
“It turns you on knowing Jamison is taking my ass?” Reed asks, giving a series of short thrusts, which causes me to slide another inch inside him.
“Yes,” she moans. “It’s been one of my most forbidden fantasies.”
Reed’s ass spasming around my cock forces a groan from me.
“Jamison, you have about two seconds to get your dick the rest of the way inside me, because I’m about to pound the fuck out of Rayn’s pussy.”
My hold on his hips tightens as I press forward, pushing the last of my cock inside him. His ass is like a vice gripping me, and I’m pretty sure I could stay inside him for hours and never be satisfied.
Reed pulls his hips back, and in tandem, we both thrust forward roughly. I fuck the hell out of him while he does the same to Rayn. Our grunts and groans and Rayn’s half-crazed cries fill the bathroom as steam billows around us.
Way too soon for my liking, my balls draw up and a tingle starts at the base of my cock. I try to hold back my orgasm, but when Rayn lets out a low cry and Reed’s thrusts pick up and his asshole contracts around my cock, I can’t stop myself. I plow into him over and over again as my release hits me hard and fast.
Once my and Reed’s rocking stops, I drop my forehead on the back of his neck as I try to catch my breath. A moment later, I feel fingers sift through my wet hair.
My cock slips free of Reed, and I take a step back. Reed has his face buried in the crook of Rayn’s neck and her eyes are on me. She gives me a soft smile.
* * *
Sometime later,the three of us are in my bed after another round of fucking. This time I took Rayn’s ass while she rode Reed.
I’m on my back with Rayn curled up against my side. One of her legs is thrown over both of mine and she plays with the hairs on my chest. I run my hand up and down the back of her thigh. Reed, propped up on an elbow, is pressed against her back with his fingers drawing designs on her side. All three of us are naked.
Dropping his head, Reed kisses the back of her neck before lifting his head again.
“I want to hear more about this forbidden fantasy of yours,” he comments. “Did you really fantasize about me and Jamison being together? Is that what you thought about when you used your toy?”
Yeah, it surprised the fuck out of me too when she revealed that in the shower.