“Make you a deal,” Tainer said, speaking to Ophelia. “First he touches her, then she blows him. How does that sound?”
“Well…all right. But only if he’s gentle,” Ophelia specified. “No gagging or choking or drooling—those are a huge turn off!”
“We’re not some kind of live sex show put here just for your entertainment, you know,” I said, hoping my voice would come out normal.
“Yes, but somebody’s gotta make you two get closer and Sorenson’s too much of a pussy to do it right,” Tainer snapped. “Now go on—get after it.” And he waved his gun at us.
But Jake shook his head.
“No—no absolutely not. Nothing below the belt,” he said and I thought he sounded like he meant it. Was this what he had been telling himself—that as long as we didn’t touch below the belt it was okay? It was a nice way to ease his conscious, but it was liable to get us killed, or at least very badly wounded.
“I said do it!” Tainer’s voice had dropped to a menacing snarl. “Go on, get a handful of that pussy and stick your fingers up in her, boy. Do it now!”
“Jake,” I said urgently, when he wouldn’t look at me. “Jake, please!”
“No.” He shook his head. “They can’t make me do that—they can’t make me hurt you like that. I won’t do it, Ani!”
“Jake, look at me.” I was still on my knees and I took his face in my hands. Staring into his eyes, I murmured, “Remember what we said. That no matter what they make us do, we won’t be mad and we won’t blame each other.”
“But Ani…I can’t,” he whispered desperately. “I mean, I shouldn’t…shouldn’t finger your soft little pussy against your will!”
“It’s not against my will,” I said firmly. Then, my heart beating like a drum, I took his free hand and pushed it between my legs.
At first Jake’s hand was a fist that he refused to unclench.
“Jake, please,” I whispered and rubbed against him, letting his knuckles graze my swollen pussy lips.
His eyes widened as he looked into mine.
“God, Ani—you’re so wet,” he murmured.
“I know.” I bit my lip, feeling the heat of shame climb my cheeks. “It, uh, really affected me when you, um, sucked my nipples,” I admitted. “But this is okay, Jake—really it is. I won’t be mad at you—I swear I won’t.”
“God, I shouldn’t!” he groaned. But then his hand was uncurling and before I knew it, he was cupping my pussy gently in his palm. He raised his eyebrows at me.
“You’ve never…?”
“Never,” I whispered, biting my lip. “You…you’ll be my first.”
“I shouldn’t do this,” he whispered and then I felt two long fingers slipping into my slippery inner folds.
“Oh, Jake!” I gasped, throwing my head back as he began to caress my inner pussy. I could feel the tip of one finger sliding around and around my throbbing clit. This was another part of my body which had previously been mute. Nothing I had tried on my own had ever had any effect—not even the vibrator Madison had given me as a joke gift last Christmas. But Jake’s touch acted like a jolt of adrenaline—he woke up that part of me, which had been asleep my whole life.
“Gently, little Ani,” I heard him murmur as he continued to stroke me with his fingertips. “We’ll take it slow and easy.”
“I…I can’t. Can’t take it easy,” I whispered. I was trembling all over at that point and I felt like there was a wire inside me—connected deep in my belly somewhere. That wire was tightening with every gentle stroke of Jake’s fingers inside me. It was getting closer and closer to snapping and I didn’t know what I would do if it did.
“Feel inside her!” Tainer demanded. “Fingerfuck her!”
“Shut up—he’s doing a perfect job as it is!” Ophelia insisted.
But Jake’s fingers were already sliding down to the entrance of my pussy.
“God, little Ani—so wet and hot,” he murmured, looking into my eyes. “Can you let me feel inside you?”
I bit my lip.
“As…as long as you’re careful.”
“I will be,” he promised and then one, long finger was slipping into my pussy mouth and sliding inside me.
He couldn’t get very far. I was, after all, a virgin, so I still had a barrier there. I winced a little, as Jake probed very gently at the sharp little pain, pressing against it caused.
“Well, what are you waiting for—I said finger fuck ‘er!” Tainer demanded.
“No—she’s a virgin. I won’t take that from her,” Jake growled. “Shoot me if you want, but I won’t do it.”
“Don’t stop touching her, though!” Ophelia protested—which was exactly what I wanted to say myself, but didn’t quite dare to. “Go on—touch her. She’s close—make her come.”
Jake looked into my eyes.
“Do you want to come, little Ani?” he murmured hoarsely. “Do you want to come while I pet your soft little pussy?”