“You liked your birthday?” she asked.
“I loved my birthday.” He checked his watch. “It’s not quite over yet, is it?”
She smiled.
Once they were all inside, all eyes were on her. She set her shawl on the back of the sofa and flicked her red hair back.
“Maybe we should do this here for a change,” she said.
He watched her slip out of her pants and tug off her sweater. She stood there in the dimly lit room in just her bra and panties.
“Look at that body,” Vinny said. “Does it belong to us?”
“You know it does,” she said. “It’s never belonged to anyone else, and certainly not my stepfather.”
“Let’s not talk about him,” Archie said, motioning her to take off more with a wave of his hand.
Gabe felt his cock stirring as she slid the first strap of her bra down. She was being a tease, moving slowly, seductively. She was usually more shy than risqué. He wasn’t complaining.
“All the way off,” Vinny said.
Her bra fell to the floor, her big, lush tits on public display. His mouth salivated with the desire to suck on her firm pink nipples.
“You may as well go all the way, baby.” Archie leaned over his knees, watching intently.
She didn’t say a word, shimmying out of her panties until she stood in the living room completely naked. Her soft, pale skin and every rounded curve were things of beauty. Her breasts sloped out into tempting peaks, her hips round and inviting.
“Touch yourself,” Gabe said.
Her eyes widened briefly, but she did as told, reaching down to touch her clit. Vinny groaned. He remained perfectly quiet, watching, imagining what he’d do to her next.
“I know it’s your birthday, but how long you going to keep us waiting?” Archie asked.
“Tonight we’re going to triple team her. Proper like.”
He knew she couldn’t complain. She’d been curious, wondering why they hadn’t claimed her together. He’d been cautiously looking forward to this day.
“Hell yeah,” Vinny said. “I’ve never seen a finer ass than hers.”
He couldn’t believe he wanted to cut her loose in the beginning. After so many failed attempts at a real relationship, he’d given up on love. Annalise made all the difference. Now that they had her, he couldn’t imagine life any other way. They were all meant to find each other.
“I’m getting chilly,” she said.
“We can’t have that, now can we?” Gabe stood up and walked toward her. She looked up at him with those big, green eyes. He used a curled finger to tilt her chin up higher. “So beautiful.”
She bit her lip.
“I’m going to fill that virgin ass with my cock tonight, so I want you nice and relaxed. Lie on the sofa and open your legs nice and wide.”
Annalise swallowed hard and did as he asked, sitting on the sofa then settling comfortably on her back. Her tits fell slightly to the sides and her knees were still closed tight.
He shook his head. “Let me see my pussy. I bet it’s glistening.”
She tentatively opened her thighs, her pink swollen pussy on full display for the three of them. They were all around the sofa now—eager and ready.
Vinny leaned over the back of the sofa and pressed two fingers deep into her slick pussy, finger fucking her over and over until she closed her eyes, her rigid body softening.
“That’s enough,” Gabe said, getting to his knees. He threw one of her legs over his shoulder, shifting her body slightly, then he delved in.
Immediately, she cried out as he lapped up her sensitive folds. He planned to enjoy her, get her loosened up enough for what they had planned. Gabe devoured her cunt, savoring her taste and the way she squirmed against his face.
He noticed Archie bending over to suck her tit deep into his mouth. Within seconds, she detonated, her pussy pulsing on his mouth, her cries filling their farmhouse.
“Get the lube from the first drawer,” Gabe said, pointing to the hall console table. Vinny rushed over, grabbing the tube.
“Got it.”
“You sure you’re ready for this?” Gabe asked her. He brushed her hair off her face. She had a nice flush now, her cheeks a pretty pink.
“I’m ready, but you have too many clothes on.”
He’d give her anything she desired. He stood and shrugged off his flannel, tossing it on the chair, then he tugged off his t-shirt, leaving him bare chested. She looked him up and down, her lips parted.
Gabe nodded to Vinny and Archie. He wasn’t going to be the only naked man in the room. They all removed their clothes until they were completely bare.
He held out a hand to her, helping her to her feet. She was a bit wobbly, but they were all there to help steady her.
After Archie took her place on the sofa, he beckoned for her to straddle him.
“Go on, Red, sit on Archie’s cock. Tell us how it feels,” Vinny said, pumping his own length as he watched her climb over Archie.