Lucy sat back on her heels. “I’m sorry, Ty. I was doing that, wasn’t I?”
“Ty doesn’t need to be shamed for his experience any more than you and I need to feel bad about our lack of experience.” Michael reached for her hand with his free one. “I’ve only been with a couple of women in my whole life, and I’m ready to explore my sexuality with the two of you. I’m open to all these experiences, and I get the feeling we’re both going to benefit from what Ty’s learned.”
And that was why he felt safe with Michael. Despite his rough exterior, there was a deep streak of kindness in the man. He was tough but he would make himself vulnerable if he thought it would help the people he cared about.
“I’m sorry,” Lucy said, her eyes starting to water.
He couldn’t have that. He moved in and kissed her cheek. “Forgiven, baby. Now ass in the air. I want to play with you.”
She resumed her position, and Michael hissed in pleasure and wound a hand in her hair.
“As to your question, no. I haven’t been in a threesome,” Michael replied, his jaw clenched. “But I have had anal sex.”
Ty reached for the glove he’d set up earlier and tugged it on his hand before grabbing the lube. “And I’ve done pretty much everything.” That sounded bad. “I mean everything consensual and sane.”
Michael chuckled. “Like I said, we’ll benefit from your experience.”
He was grateful for his experience now. If he and Lucy had gotten together back when they were kids, they likely wouldn’t have experimented at all. They might not have moved to Bliss. They likely would have stayed close to their parents and already started a family. There was nothing wrong with that, but there also wasn’t anything wrong with seeing a bit of the world, learning something of who they were individually before they became a couple.
They definitely wouldn’t have become a threesome.
He wouldn’t have figured out how much he was looking forward to sharing Lucy with a friend. “You keep doing what you’re doing, baby. Don’t you mind me.”
Michael groaned again, tugging lightly on her hair. “I almost wish I could see what you’re doing.”
“She needs to wear the plug for a few days.” Ty spread her cheeks, and there was a pretty little asshole. She was going to be so tight around him. But after she got used to the plug, not so tight it was uncomfortable for her. “I’ll show you how to plug her. And after she’s been a very good girl and taken her plug, she’ll get a cock, too.”
His cock. He would make love to her for the first time. She would be the last woman he ever made love to because no matter what Michael eventually decided, Ty was going to stay with her for the rest of his life.
He dribbled lube right on her asshole and heard her gasp, saw her whole body go tight.
He couldn’t have that. “Relax, baby. Don’t worry about a thing. You’re going to learn to love this.”
“I know I love this,” Michael declared.
Well, it was obvious that the distraction he was providing was working because Lucy seemed to relax.
He rimmed her asshole, massaging the lube in. A shudder went through her, and he heard Michael groan again as Lucy made a whimpering sound around his dick.
It made Ty’s jump at the thought of having her pretty mouth around it, but that was for another day. He wanted to be inside her, looking down into her eyes as they finally came together the way they were always meant to.
He worked one finger in, slowly willing her to open for him, making sure he lubed every inch of that rosebud of hers. Then he picked up the plug. All the while Lucy kept working Michael’s cock. As Ty started to press the plug inside, easing it in and out, he could see the way Michael’s whole body had tightened.
Lucy started to move in a rhythm that helped him push the plug deeper and deeper. She was fucking the plug, and Ty reacted to the sight. His arousal went through the roof, blood pulsing through him. His dick was going to go off if he didn’t get inside her soon.
“It feels weird, but I don’t hate it.” Lucy had lifted her torso back now that she’d finished Michael off, and she twisted slightly so she could see Ty. Her lips were full and red from the work they’d just done, and she looked a bit like the cat who’d gotten all the cream.
She tilted her hips up and the plug slid home.
Ty stepped back. “Good. I need you to keep that in. I can promise you I’m going to love how that plug feels while I fuck you.”
He pulled the glove off his hand and laid it back on the tray, picking up the condoms and rolling one on with shaking hands. He loved her. He was going to make love to the woman he loved, and his heart raced at the thought. He stroked himself, making sure the condom was on properly. He wasn’t about to risk anything with her. One day they might talk about kids, but they needed time to themselves, time to build a strong relationship.