I didn’t rush anything, despite how hard we both were. I let my eyes roam over Cain’s thick shaft. He was beautifully built and thicker than I’d realized, though that shouldn’t have surprised me considering how full I’d felt the night before when he’d slid into me. He was bigger than Eric, but despite that and the fact that he’d never been with a man before, he’d still been gentler with me than Eric had ever been, even when he’d taken my virginity.
I pushed thoughts of my ex out of my head and focused on the amazing man before me. I nuzzled his cock before tentatively licking the length of the entire shaft. I’d performed oral sex on Eric countless times and he’d been an exacting teacher, so I knew how to bring Cain pleasure, but I still couldn’t help but be nervous. I shifted my eyes up to make sure Cain was still good and saw that he had his head pressed back against the wall and his eyes were closed. I licked him a few more times and then teased his balls with gentle licks and kisses. It wasn’t until he groaned my name that I shifted enough to be able to suck his crown into my mouth. His hips immediately punched forward and I automatically grabbed his base with my hand so he wouldn’t instinctively shove his cock down my throat since that was what I was used to. But unlike Eric, I knew Cain wouldn’t take pleasure in watching me gag on his flesh as he used my mouth.
I cursed myself for letting Eric get into my head again. I took more of Cain’s stiffness into my mouth and sucked gently. I felt Cain’s hand settle on my head, but he didn’t try to control me or hold me in place so he could jam his cock down my throat. I was disappointed in myself that I’d even thought such a thing was a possibility, but I figured, like Cain, I had to knock some holes in my own walls before they’d completely fall.
It took just a couple of minutes to relax my gag reflex enough to deep throat Cain’s cock and I languished in the sensation of him filling me so completely, but in such a different way. I loved that he was letting me control the pace, though I knew there’d be a day where I would revel in him fucking my mouth however he wanted.
“Fuck, so good, Ethan,” I heard Cain say and I lifted my eyes so I could look at him. His face was drawn tight with lust and I marveled at the way he watched me. His finger came up to stroke my cheek gently as he began thrusting in and out of my mouth in soft, short glides. I rolled his balls in my hand as I increased the suction. Cain’s eyes closed again and then both his hands were in my hair. He fucked my mouth harder, but never gave me more than I could handle. He was just as aware of me as I was of him.
I used my free hand to stroke my own cock as I worked Cain over. His pulsing flesh was proof of how close he was. He was panting heavily now and the sound had my own orgasm nipping at the edge of my sanity. I wanted Cain to come before me, so I released my dick and reached up to grab his ass like I had the night before. I forced him forward as deep as he could go, ignoring the stinging in my eyes as my gag reflex started to kick in. I risked letting my fingers slide through his crease and when he didn’t jerk away from my touch, I pressed one of my fingers over his hole. Cain let out a rough curse and then he took over, surging into my mouth and then back against my finger. He came within a matter of seconds. As the first ropes of cum trickled down my throat, I grabbed my dick and jerked hard and fast. He was still spewing in my mouth as my own release hit me. I cried out around his dick and then tore my mouth away as the orgasm consumed me. I felt cum hitting my mouth and chin, but didn’t care because I was too blinded by my own climax to do anything but glide my hand up and down my wet shaft so I could ride out every second of the blissful pleasure. I was being dragged to my feet moments later and then a heavy mouth was crashing down on mine.
I was stunned when Cain licked up the remnants of his cum. It was something Eric had hated with a passion. But that wasn’t enough for Cain because then he was grabbing my hand and licking my fingers clean before the water could wash away what was left of my own juices. Then Cain’s mouth was back on mine and I could taste our mixed flavors as he kissed me.