It took a few minutes, but by the time Denver was groaning and pounding into me, I was nearly there. The other guys worked my nipples, squeezed my breasts… there were so many hands on me that I couldn’t keep track of who was where, but it felt good. It felt right. Like this was where I was supposed to be.
When Denver cried out, I echoed him a few seconds later, my body trembling like mad. It wasn’t quite as powerful as the first time, but it still made me scream. Then Denver collapsed on the bed next to me, and I rolled on my side, my face against his chest. We lay there for a few minutes, both of us panting.
A large, warm presence moved against my back. Knox snaked his arm around my waist. God, it felt good. A hard male body behind me and in front. Austin was on the other side of Denver, looking down at us, and Tonio sat at the foot of the bed.
“That was incredible,” Denver said, still sounding a bit winded.
“That’s what I was going to say.” I smiled at him.
“Ours was too,” Tonio said. “I couldn’t say anything at the time because you didn’t want to know who it was.”
Austin cocked an eyebrow. “What made you change your mind?”
I thought about it as I fought the pleasant drowsiness that stole through me. “I just realized that it didn’t really matter who was touching me where—because we’re all part of this. We’re all in this together.”
“Yeah, we are,” Denver said, and he brought my hand to his lips.
I smiled as he kissed each finger. “I never knew it could be like this.”
“The sex?” Austin asked.
“Well, yes, that too, but I meant this connection.” My sleepiness faded away and suddenly I was able to clarify the feelings I’d been having all night. “I didn’t think it was possible to have feelings for more than one person, but it is. It’s like… I don’t know, like maybe finding the perfect table for your dining room. You see it and you fall in love with the whole thing, not just the table. It’s all part of it… the chairs, the leaf in the middle, everything. Each piece is important.”
Warmth filled me as I looked at each of the three men I could see.
Then Tonio said, “Did you just compare us to a dinette set?”
The tension broke and we all laughed. Knox’s abs and pecs vibrated as he laughed behind me, and his massive cock pressed against my ass. Which brought an interesting question to mind. “So, um, if Tonio went first because he was the only one I met at the club, and Denver went next because he heard me wake up and came up to talk to me, then… who would be next? Because when I came down to the kitchen, both Knox and Austin were there.”
“That’s a question for next time,” Tonio said.
I shifted my hips, deliberately brushing against Knox’s cock. He squeezed his arm tighter around my waist and growled in my ear. “Be good, princess.”
Austin had caught our byplay. “I suppose that technically, we both met her at the same time.”
Tonio glared at him. “She’s exhausted.”
I gave him an innocent smile. “Do I look like I’m falling asleep?” I ground my ass against Knox again, and he groaned as if in pain.
Austin grinned. “I’ve seen her fall asleep right after a good orgasm—and that’s not what this looks like.”
Denver was clearly on Tonio’s side. “Emma, honey, it’s late. We’ve all had a good time—there will be other nights.”
“Yeah, Emma, there’s no hurry,” Tonio added.
“Said the two men who’ve already come,” I said slyly.
Austin laughed and fisted his cock, which was growing bigger by the moment. But then he looked past me, and whatever expression was on Knox’s face caused Austin to let go of his hardened cock.
“She’s had enough,” Knox growled.
His hand was still curled around my waist. I grabbed his hand and tugged it upward until it touched my breast. “Shouldn’t I be the judge of that?”
Austin whistled softly. “I’m really liking this side of you.”
I grinned at him and winked.
“So do you remember which one of us you saw first?” he asked.
I mulled over the question for a moment. I knew what answer I wanted to give—but it would require taking more initiative than I had the entire night. Up until now, it had been the men calling the shots. “I’m pretty sure I saw you and Knox at the exact same moment.”
Austin got my meaning instantly, and he stroked his cock again, his eyes gleaming. Knox must have gotten it a moment later because he swore in my ear. “No.”
“Yes,” I said. I shifted my hips upward. His hard cock was pressed against my ass. If I could only get it between my legs…