She pulled off Caleb’s cock, and nodded. “Yes.”
“Good girl.”
Pumping inside her, he stroked over her anus, getting her used to feel of him. After a few minutes, he pushed his finger inside her. At first, the tight ring of muscles held him back, and he didn’t stop. Pressing against her ass, she relented, and he filled her to the knuckle.
Taking his time, he got her used to his finger before adding a second, and when she could take them both, he spread her open, scissoring his fingers.
“I’m taking her ass,” he said.
Pulling out of her pussy, he gripped his length and coated it with the lube Caleb bought, and the pressed the tip at her ass. He made sure to go slow, waiting for her to open up to him.
“Relax for me, sweetheart. Don’t tense up.”
She released a little gasp, and he paused, waiting for her ass to open up to him.
When she started to press back against his cock, he gripped her hips, and inch by inch, he filled her virgin asshole until he was balls deep.
“How are you feeling?” Caleb asked.
“It feels … weird,” she said.
Caleb pushed some of her hair off her face, and Damon closed his eyes, feeling her ass tighten around him. Fuck, it was even tighter than her pussy.
“Are you ready for me inside you?” Caleb asked.
“Yes!” She was panting now, wanton and eager.
Damon moved so that he was on the floor. His cock still deep within her ass, and she was spread open, ready to take Caleb. She held onto his hands, and when his brother pressed inside her pussy, he groaned.
With every added inch, her ass squeezed him even more.
“I knew this was going to be good but I didn’t realize it was going to be this fucking good,” Caleb said.
“I feel so full, so out of control,” said Opal.
“Let go, baby. Enjoy yourself.”
Caleb worked his cock inside her pussy until fully seated, and they both stayed still, giving her time. Only when she was ready did they both move, creating a rhythm that took the pleasure to the next level.
The instant he saw Opal, he knew she was the one but right now, deep inside her, loving her with his brother, there was no doubt.
He loved her more than anything else in the world, and would give her whatever her heart desired. She held his hand, kissed his brother, and thrust against both of them, taking and giving with equal measure, and he fucking loved it, more than anything.
She was incredible.
“You feel so good,” Caleb said.
“The best,” Damon agreed with him.
“Please, I need it, please,” she said, begging.
Reaching between her thighs, he teased her clit. With a few strokes, she came apart, screaming their names. Her release set off his orgasm as her ass squeezed him like a vise. He saw stars dance before his eyes as he filled her with wave upon wave of release.
Seconds later, he heard Caleb groan. All three of them finding their pleasure with each other. He couldn’t help but wonder when she’d become ripe with their child. He could hardly wait.
They collapsed on the floor before the fire. The comforting scent of burning wood and cedar mixed with the dinner waiting for them.
“Do you think we’ll ever make it to the bedroom?” Opal asked.