I weigh up my options. I’m trapped in here. I’m not going to get out unless I give him something he wants. So, I offer him the thing I’m most willing to give him, and hope to God he accepts my offer.
“My mouth,” I whisper. “You can have my mouth.”
“I can?” he mocks me. “I know I can, toy, but thank you for offering nonetheless, it’s terribly sweet of you. Don’t you think so, Caspian?”
“Yes,” his friend says with a cruel smile playing on his face. “I definitely think so.”
“I just wonder if you’re only being so nice because you’re really just a little whore desperate for something down your throat,” Dex says thoughtfully. “Or if it really is my cock that you want.”
I struggle with an answer, not knowing what to tell him to stop him from hurting me. But it’s my silence that seals my fate in the end.
“I think she doesn’t care whose cock it is,” Caspian speaks up next. “I think she’s so desperate to be a little whore, it doesn’t even matter to her which one of us does all the bad stuff she’s been dreaming about.”
“That’s not t-true,” I stutter, but they pay me no mind, exchanging amused glances as I struggle to get the words out. “You’re making me do this. You’re making me choose between something awful and something even worse!”
“Yeah, sure,” Caspian laughs out loud. “As if anyone’s going to buy that you don’t want this, little girl. We can all tell how desperate for cock you are. It’s practically written on your goddamn face.”
“I think you should definitely suck some cock,” Dexter tells me resolutely. “If nothing else, to teach you a fucking lesson. You’re forgetting yourself here, Pandora.”
He touches the bulge in his pants, and I glare at him as an idea strikes me. I’m nervous as fuck, but I have to do this. I have to defy him. I have to stop letting the Firstborns walk all over me.
“Fine,” I say, dropping to my knees in front of him and looking up into his smug face. “Can I just have one small request, please?”
“Sure,” Dexter grins widely at me. “Anything for my favorite toy of the moment.”
I motion toward Caspian without taking my eyes off Dex’s. “I want to suck him.”
His expression falls just as Caspian roars to life, laughing at me.
“Such a desperate slut,” he says, taking Dexter’s place and practically pushing him out of the way. “It’s your call, Pandora, and we did say we’d do what you wanted, didn’t we?”
“Yes, you did,” I purr, my eyes finally leaving Dexter’s shocked face and going to Caspian before me. “Why don’t you give it to me then? After all, I’m fucking desperate for it.”
He doesn’t need to be told twice, undoing the zipper of his pants and pulling out a huge cock that’s throbbing in shades of red and purple. Even his goddamn dick looks pissed off.
I lick my lips, throwing Dexter one last look before Caspian buries his impressive length in my throat.
“Two cocks in one day,” he says breathlessly. “Looks like you’ve finally fucking found your calling, little girl.”
I start to suck clumsily, and he doesn’t leave any room for me to make mistakes, burying himself in my throat by grabbing the back of my head and forcing his cock deep inside me. He throbs in my mouth, sending spurt after spurt of precum into me, filling me up to the very brim.
Dexter stands behind Caspian, and I can tell just how pissed off he is. But this is what I wanted after all.
I look up at my former fiancé, my eyes wide as they meet his with my mouth full of another boy’s cock. Dexter is fuming, and I can tell he won’t let me get away with this. He takes a step back, rounding Caspian until he’s standing behind me. He lands a hard slap against my ass, making me let out a muffled yelp. Then, he flips up my school uniform, exposing my ass in nothing but a thong beneath the skirt.
He touches his fingertips to my ass, and I stop sucking, fear taking ahold of me as he explores the contours of my hips.
“Keep fucking sucking,” Dexter reminds me icily. “I’m not going to tell you twice. You wanted this, so don’t stop for a fucking second, toy.”
I look up at Caspian whose cruel gaze is glued to the spot where my lips join his cock. I can feel him throbbing in my mouth, and I lick a line along his vein, tasting him deep in my throat.
“Now this might hurt a little,” Dex speaks up from behind me before spitting on me.
I shiver. It’s so fucking degrading, the way he treats me, yet I want nothing more than for him to keep going. A sudden desire to make him jealous overcomes me, and I suck on Caspian’s cock harder, filling my mouth with the taste and feel of him and loving the way it feels on my tongue.
I can feel Dexter’s fingertips on me, parting my ass. I let out a muffled moan when his fingers touch my puckered hole, exploring the opening with surprising gentleness.
Caspian pulls out of my mouth, showing off his cock that’s wet with my spit and allowing me to speak freely. Dexter leans in closer, his fingers massaging my asshole and making me cry out with a combination of fear and pleasure.