I knew the moment he did it when her eyes widened in surprise. “Tyler!”
“Stay still. We'll hold you this time, but you will present yourself for your training.”
She shook her head. “No, I don’t want to. It’s going to hurt. I saw how Cross had his fingers inside of Olivia. I don’t want that.”
“Was she being hurt?” I asked.
She winced and groaned as Tyler continued to play. She shifted away.
“Stop moving.” Tyler’s words didn’t keep her from trying to get away from his probing fingers.
I put my hands on her shoulders, held her still. “Reach back, Emily, grab your ass and spread yourself open for Tyler.”
Her eyes widened. “What? I can’t do that.”
“You can and you will.”
Tyler spanked her bottom.
“Tyler!” she cried, her legs tightening about my hips. “I don’t want that plug.”
“You want your husbands to claim you, don’t you? This is so we don’t hurt you. Like we said, Xander’s going to fill your ass for the first time with his cock while I fuck your pussy. Together. But not until you’re ready, until your ass is properl
y stretched.”
“But—”
“Do you want him to spank you more?” I asked.
“No!”
“Then spread yourself open for him.”
“I don’t like this.”
I had to get her mind to agree with her body, so I swiped my fingers through her wetness. Our seed. “This shows you like it. Remember, sweetheart.” With my other hand, I reached up and stroked her hair back from her face. It had fallen loose from the pins as we’d fucked her. “We might not give you what you want. We’ll give you what you need.”
“I don’t need to have that thing in me,” she countered. I saw the heat in her eyes and this time it was in anger. My cock twitched at seeing her so riled.
“Two choices, baby,” Tyler leaned down, kissed the nape of her neck, then murmured in her ear. “Reach back and hold yourself open for me or get spanked before you do it.”
Her eyes narrowed as she stared at me. Slowly, she reached back and did as we said. I could see her hands holding herself open, but it was the pleased expression on Tyler’s face as he moved back and looked at her that I knew she’d done as we said.
“Good girl,” he said.
Tyler didn’t delay. Slowly and carefully, he worked her with his finger, using the seed that coated her pussy as lubricant.
“What a pretty pink hole, baby. Are we the first to touch you here?”
She nodded as she held her breath, her breasts thrust out.
“She’s tight. I’m in.”
When her mouth fell open and she began to pant, I knew he was finger fucking her ass. Her dark eyes met mine and held. I watched the play of emotions I could see there. Anger, surprise, discomfort and finally, yes… arousal.
Tyler slipped the plug from her pussy. “This plug is nice and coated, baby. It’s going to slide right in. Just like Xander’s cock. Relax, take a deep breath and let it out. Good.”
Her eyes widened and she groaned, long and low. While she didn’t want to have her ass breached, she kept her hands in position.