He stood, then surprised her by offering her a helping hand. A trick, surely. She declined by pushing to her feet under her own steam. Besides, she’d seen some of the places those hands had been. And, really, she didn’t need to know what they felt like. If they were callused and rough...hot enough to make her burn and quiver the way Tawny and countless others had.
“What are you doing here?” he asked.
Why not tell him the truth? He had only to ask the townsfolk about her to hear a thousand stories detailing her reign of terror in high school. Perhaps some kind soul would even mention the time a poll was pinned to the corkboard in the town square: “If given a choice, who would you rather torture? The devil or Harlow Glass?”
Harlow had won by a landslide.
“I’m Harlow Glass, and I used to live here.”
His gaze raked over her once, then again far more slowly. “I’m honored. Harlow Glass in the flesh. A sighting rarer than Bigfoot.”
How did he know? It wasn’t as if he’d ever had a reason to look for her.
And oh, wow. His voice. He’d pumped up the smoke, making it even better than before, captivating and temping, sending cascades of pleasure rippling through her.
Danger! Danger! She widened the distance between them.
“Oh, no, you don’t. We’re going back to the house.” He waved her forward.
Stay strong. “How cute. You made a funny.”
His expression hardened, promising severe consequences if she refused him a second time, and yet his tenor softened, no longer quite so menacing. “My apologies for not being clear, sweetheart. You’re coming with me, and that’s that.”
“No, that’s not that. I have no desire to watch another mouth-to-mouth sesh with Tawny. Let’s just conclude our business here.”
The smile he unveiled lacked any sort of humor, and yet it utterly devastated her senses, leaving her reeling. “You have two options. One—we discuss the theft and destruction of my pie within the privacy of my home, and just how you’re going to make it up to me. Or two—I call Sheriff Lintz.”
Dang it! He had her by the lady balls, and he knew it. “Look. You could waterboard me, but I still won’t confess—”
“Good to know I have your permission to waterboard.”
“—to a crime, so why don’t I say I’m sorry for interrupting your evening, and we call it good?”
“Does that sorry come with a side of pie?”
“No,” she said through gritted teeth.
“Then we won’t be good.”
Figured. “So...what? You expect me to bake you another one?”
“Yes, ma’am, I surely do.”
“Are you going to ask me a thousand questions about how I did what I allegedly did, or why I did what I allegedly did?”
“Do I look like a guy who cares about how and why?”
No. No, he didn’t. He looked like a guy who didn’t care about much of anything—except pleasure. “Okay. All right.” Anything to (1) continue to keep him away from her camp, (2) speed up their parting and (3) appease him so the matter stayed between the two of them. But he was in for an unpleasant surprise. Her mother hadn’t given her the title of Worst Chef in History for nothing. “You win.”
Head high, she marched past him. He didn’t lag behind for long, was soon keeping pace beside her, his hand light on her lower back. The action was meant to ensure she stayed the course, but the heat of him pricked at her, made her itch for...something.
“You do know baking a pie takes several hours, right?” At least, it had for her mother. “Are you going to trust me in the kitchen, alone, while you and Tawny conclude your business?”
“Tawny will have to wait. In a contest between sex and pie, sex will lose every time.”
“Wow,” she said, rolling her eyes. “No wonder panties drop in your presence. Your words are poetry.”
“Are you trying to tell me your panties have already dropped?”
She peered up at him, incredulous, then stunned. Waning sunlight hit him just right, stroking him with muted golden rays, making him almost inhumanly beautiful. Definitely otherworldly. The ache returned to her chest.
“The day my panties drop for you,” she said without any sharpness, “is the day I want to be taken behind one of the sheds and shot.”
“Because you’ll know you’ll never have me again and you won’t be able to live with the pain?”
She snorted, oddly charmed by his warped sense of humor.
No. Not oddly. He knew what he was doing.
“Yeah,” she said drily. “Something like that.”
Mirth glittered in those golden eyes, the corners of his mouth twitching. “Very well. I promise to make it as quick and painless as possible.”
How kind. “Let’s backtrack. Earlier you looked at me as if you knew me. You also hinted you’d searched for me. Why?”
His amusement drained in a snap. “Perhaps you’re mistaking shock for familiarity.”
She wasn’t the greatest at reading people, but she wasn’t the worst, either. “The two aren’t even close to similar.”
“You find the thought of meeting me and forgetting me more plausible?”
Well. That was certainly a good point, wasn’t it?
As they passed the line of trees, Tawny came into view. The girl waited on the porch, her hands braced on the railing where the initials H.G. were carved, her upper arms pushing her breasts together. As if she really needed the help. She was short and curvy, a real live pinup compared to Harlow’s too-slender frame.