Mike raised his eyebrows encouragingly. Aria pulled a notebook out of her bag and slid it across the desk. “We don’t have too much time, since the arraignment is Friday, so I wrote down everything that’s happened so you can look it over at your leisure.” Inside the notebook were also drawings she’d started for Asher Trethewey. Not that she’d need them now.
Sturbridge waved his hand. “That won’t be necessary. I think I’ve got all I need.”
Aria and Mike exchanged a look. “But you haven’t got anything,” Aria said. “Don’t you want to know what really happened that night?”
“Lord, no.” Sturbridge looked abashed. “Miss Montgomery, this is a tricky case. There are eyewitnesses, there’s a video of you on the scene . . . it doesn’t look very good. The way I see it, there’s really only one way to play this case so you come out a winner.”
“What’s that?” Mike asked.
“We plead insanity.”
He looked pleased with himself, like he’d discovered a new law of gravity. Aria blinked hard. “But I’m not insane.”
One eyebrow rose. “Hallucinating that Alison DiLaurentis is alive? Sending bullying notes to yourself?”
“Those notes weren’t from me!” Aria cried.
Sturbridge smiled sadly. “The police say they are.”
Mike’s shoulders drooped. “You’re using information you read about my sister online, stuff the cops came up with. That isn’t her in the video.”
Sturbridge frowned. “It certainly looks like her.”
“It’s not,” Aria said. “I didn’t do it.”
Sturbridge formed an X with his pointer fingers. “Don’t want to hear it!” he singsonged. Then he passed a stapled set of papers across the desk. “If you want to stay out of a Jamaican prison, you’ll sign this insanity plea. It will get you a stay and a psychiatric evaluation. It’s not so bad. Chances are, you’ll end up in one of those cushy mental hospitals around here, all expenses paid by the state.”
“Like the Preserve at Addison-Stevens?” Aria challenged.
Sturbridge’s eyes lit up. “Exactly! I hear the food is amazing there.”
Aria shut her eyes and forced herself to take calming breaths.
Mike flung the papers back at Sturbridge. “Thanks for your time, but you’re nuts, man.” He grabbed the notebook from the lawyer and took Aria’s arm. “C’mon.”
“You’ll regret it!” Sturbridge called out as they fled down the hall.
“Sorry,” Mike said, pushing the door open. He looked miserable. “If I had known that’s what he was going to go for, I would have never put you through that.”
“It’s okay,” Aria mumbled, staring blankly at a bunch of overweight ladies congregating in front of Curves. So much for the lawyer route.
She felt her phone buzz in her pocket. She grabbed it and looked at the message. I’m back on the hunt, Emily had written. Are you in or out? In the same thread, Hanna had responded to count her in. A minute later, Spencer had said yes, too.
“What’s that?” Mike asked, leaning over. Aria was about to cover the screen, but Mike had already seen the text. His face brightened. “Yes. You’re going after Ali again?”
“You’re not getting involved,” Aria said quickly.
Mike slumped. “Why not? I know everything. I can help. You have nothing to lose.”
Aria shut her eyes. “I’m sorry,” she said. “I just can’t let you help.”
Mike’s face fell. “In the immortal words of that freak-job lawyer, you’ll regret it.”
Aria shoved her phone back in her pocket. No, she’d regret it if she did let him help. She’d lost too much already. She couldn’t lose her brother, too.
It was raining when Aria biked up to the curb behind the local Wawa several hours later, after dark. She spied her old friends standing near the woods that divided the mini-mart from an apartment complex and started toward them. Her shoes immediately sank into the mud. Raindrops pelted her cheeks. She pulled her hoodie over her head and ran.
Spencer inhaled shakily when they had all assembled. “Okay. How are we going to do this? What do we have on Ali that we can look into?”
Everyone was quiet. A milk truck chugged into Wawa and parked around the side. Then Emily cleared her throat. “I got a voicemail from Ali. She was laughing at me. At us.”
Aria’s eyes widened. “Ali called you?”
“Why would she do that?” Spencer whispered, her stomach swirling.
“I don’t know.” Emily placed her hands on her hips. “But she did.”
“Maybe she thought you were the least likely to tell on her,” Spencer suggested.
“Well, she was wrong.” Emily pulled out her phone. They gathered around and listened to the voicemail. When Aria heard the high-pitched giggle, a shiver wriggled up her spine.
“I can’t believe it,” Hanna murmured, turning pale. “Do you think she meant to call you, or did so by accident?”
Emily shut her eyes. “I have no idea.”
“Should we send this to Fuji?” Aria asked after a beat.
Spencer snorted. “She’ll think we made it up. It probably comes from our phones for all we know.”
Aria looked at Emily. “Play it again.”
Emily did as she was told. Aria listened once more as that familiar laugh twirled through the air. “It sounds like she’s in a crowd, don’t you think?”